SC dismisses ED appeal against HC order allowing Bharathi Reddy to replace attached assets with FDs
The Hindu
SC declines ED's appeal against Telangana HC order allowing Y.S. Bharathi Reddy, wife of Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy, to substitute property attached by ED in money laundering case with fixed deposits; Bench notes property attached was not actual one acquired from proceeds of crime.
The Supreme Court on July 14 declined to entertain an appeal by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) against a Telangana High Court decision allowing Y.S. Bharathi Reddy, the wife of Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Jaganmohan Reddy, to substitute the property attached by the central agency in a money laundering case with fixed deposits.
A Bench of Justices AS Oka and Sanjay Karol asked whether the immovable property attached by the agency was the proceeds of the alleged crime.
Additional Solicitor General S. Raju, for the ED, said they were not, but amounted to the “equivalent value”.
Senior advocate Niranjan Reddy and advocate Liz Mathew appeared for Ms. Reddy. They referred to several portions of the High Court order which had concluded that the property attached were not the actual proceeds of the alleged crime.
The property was attached by the ED under money laundering charges in a corruption case involving Bharathi Cement.
Refusing to intervene in the High Court order, the apex court noted that “the property attached was not the actual one that was acquired from the proceeds of the crime. This finding is not disputes by the petitioner [ED]. Moreover, it is not the case of the petitioner that the value of the attached property mentioned in the order [of the Telangana High Court] is incorrect. In view of this factual position, we decline to entertain the special leave petition,” the Bench recorded in the order.
According to the ED’s special leave petition, the High Court, in its order on November 28 last year, “erringly directed the release of the confirmed attached immovable property pertaining to the respondent [Ms. Reddy] in lieu of fixed deposit for a sum of ₹ 1,36,91,285”.
“We are judges and therefore, cannot act like Mughals of a bygone era ... the writ courts in the guise of doing justice cannot transcend the barriers of law,” the High Court of Karnataka observed while setting aside an order of a single judge, who in 2016 had extended the lease of a public premises allotted to a physically challenged person to 20 years contrary to 12-year period stipulated in the law.
The High Court of Karnataka on Monday declined to interfere, at present, in the investigation against a Bharatiya Janata Party worker, who is among the accused persons facing charges of circulating obscene clips, related to “morphed” images and videos clips related to Prajwal Revanna, former Hassan MP, in public domain through pen drives and other modes.
The 16th edition of Bhoomi Habba was held on June 8, at the Visthar campus. The festival drew a vibrant crowd who came together to celebrate eco-consciousness through a variety of engaging activities, creative workshops, panel discussions, interactive exhibits and performances, all centered around this year’s theme: “Save Water, Save Lives.”