Pleas in SC challenge Patna HC verdict upholding Bihar caste-based survey

SC petitions challenge Bihar caste-based survey, claiming it usurps Centre's powers. Petitions allege survey violates Constitution, Census Act & Rules. State lacks competence to issue survey notification, say pleas.

Multiple petitions challenging the Bihar caste-based survey were filed in the Supreme Court on Thursday, claiming that the survey was an attempt by the Nitish Kumar government to “usurp” the Centre’s powers.

The petitions have appealed against a Patna High Court decision on August 1, upholding the legality of the State’s June 6, 2022 order notifying the survey.

One of the petitioners, Akhilesh Kumar, said that the State lacked the competence to issue the survey notification.

Also read | Why Nitish Kumar is counting on a caste count in Bihar

“The notification is against the constitutional mandate of distribution of powers between the State and the Union Legislature enshrined under Article 246 of the Constitution,” the petition said. It added that the survey also violated Schedule VII of the Constitution; the Census Act, 1948; and the Census Rules, 1990.

The petitions highlighted that the census was enumerated at Entry 69 in the Union List in the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution. “Therefore, only the Union has the authority to conduct census in India and the State government had no authority to decide and notify the conduct of caste-based survey in Bihar. The notification is null and void,” they contended.

The pleas said that the notification was ultra vires, or beyond the powers of Sections 3, 4, and 4A of the Census Act, 1948, as well as Rules 3, 4 and 6A of the Census Rules, 1990.