PMK’s pitch for a Dalit Chief Minister in Tamil Nadu stirs political debate

VCK founder's comments spark debate on Dalit representation in Tamil Nadu politics, PMK promises SC Chief Minister.

While most political parties in Tamil Nadu are fervent advocates of social justice and equality, Viduthalai Chiruthaigal Katchi (VCK) founder Thol. Thirumavalavan’s recent comments that it would be highly unlikely that a Dalit would become a Chief Minister in India calls for a serious introspection.

Mr. Thirumavalavan had pointed out last week that barring a few exceptional cases such as the earlier rise of Mayawati and her Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) in Uttar Pradesh, it would be difficult for a political party and a leader to get elected by propagating Ambedkarite ideas in India

A few days later, Pattali Makkal Katchi (PMK) president Anbumani Ramadoss said his party would make a member of the Scheduled Castes (SC) the Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu, if it receives support from the community. This has reignited a political debate over the political representation of Dalits in a ‘progressive’ Tamil Nadu.

Subsequently, PMK founder S. Ramadoss said he does not agree with the assertion that a Dalit can never become a Chief Minister and there is no ‘magic’ needed to achieve it.

“If the Vanniyar community is the single biggest community in Tamil Nadu, the Schedule Caste community is the single largest grouping of castes. If they come together, it would be possible to capture power. At the same time, nobody can form a government without the support of these two communities. Yet, there has been no Chief Ministers from either of these two communities. Why?” he asked.

Mr. Ramadoss pointed out that almost 30 years ago, his party had said it would make a Dalit the Chief Minister of the State.

“In 2016, when the PMK contested alone, we announced that we would nominate two deputy Chief Ministers, one of whom would be a Dalit and the other from a southern district. With a view to elect a Chief Minister from the SC community, I have worked with former Congress leader L. Elayaperumal, P.V. Kariamal, Sakthidasan, Dr. Seppan, Vai. Balasundaram, Poovai M. Moorthy, and Thirumavalavan. But it was not possible. The people are not the reason for that... it is because of a conspiracy by those who have been in power. This is why neither a Vanniyar nor an SC has been able to become the Chief Minister,” he said.