‘Wasn’t consulted’: Maharashtra language panel chief on Hindi row

The Maharashtra government’s decision to make Hindi a compulsory third language from Classes 1 to 5 is in contravention of the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020, Laxmikant Deshmukh, the chairperson of the Maharashtra government-appointed Language Consultation Committee, told The Hindu on Monday.

The Maharashtra government’s decision to make Hindi a compulsory third language from Classes 1 to 5 is in contravention of the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020, Laxmikant Deshmukh, the chairperson of the Maharashtra government-appointed Language Consultation Committee, told The Hindu on Monday.

Also Read: Why is the three-language policy controversial? | Explained

Mr. Deshmukh said the panel was opposed to the State government’s move on the grounds of educational, cultural and practical implementation. He said the move is neither conducive to children’s psychological growth nor is it practical due to the woefully inadequate school infrastructure for primary education.

The committee has already written a letter to Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis advising to revoke the decision.

Part of the NEP 2020, Maharashtra’s decision was announced on April 17 and mandates that Hindi be taught alongside Marathi and English.

However, Mr. Deshmukh said the NEP does not talk about the third language for primary education until a child turns 11. “As per the NEP, there should be only two languages – R1 [the language employed as the medium of instruction and for initial literacy attainment. Ideally, the mother tongue or regional language that is most familiar to students] and R2 [any other language, including English or a foreign language] – till the child turns 11. But the State government has claimed that the decision has been taken on the basis of recommendations of the State Council of Educational Research and Training. But their earlier draft, which was made open for public consultation and comments, did not have it,” Mr. Deshmukh contended.

Formed after five years of consultations, NEP 2020, which replaces the previous education policy of 1986, has stated that wherever possible, the medium of instruction for students in both public and private schools until at least Class 5, but preferably till Class 8 and beyond, will be in the home language or the mother tongue or the local language or the regional language. Thereafter, the home or local language shall continue to be taught as a language wherever possible. The NEP 2020 introduces the three-language formula, encouraging students to learn -- R1, R2, and R3 (a third language). While it encourages the use of the mother tongue/local language until at least Class 5 (preferably beyond), it does not limit language learning to just R1 and R2. State governments and school boards have the flexibility to choose which languages to offer, but the three-language formula remains the overarching framework.