
Ordered to pay Rs 12,000 alimony, man claims Rs 9,000 salary. Court's response
India Today
The Supreme Court questioned a man's claim that he earns only Rs 325 per day and cannot pay Rs 12,000 monthly alimony, calling it "impossible" in present times.
During a hearing on a divorce plea, the Supreme Court questioned a man’s claim that he could not afford to pay Rs 12,000 per month as maintenance to his wife because he earns only Rs 325 per day as a daily wager. The man told the court that even after working tirelessly throughout the month, he managed to earn only around Rs 9,000 and therefore could pay Rs 12,000 as maintenance.
A bench of Justice Vikram Nath and Justice Sandeep Mehta expressed disbelief over the claim, observing that it was difficult to accept that anyone earns so little in present times.
The bench remarked that it was hard to believe that any company would pay less than the minimum daily wage and even expressed its inclination to summon the firm, Hindustan Auto Agency, which the husband claimed employed him at such low wages. The court questioned which company pays such meagre wages today and said the assertion did not appear credible.
The husband’s counsel, George Pothan, defended his client’s statement, saying that the husband was truthfully disclosing his daily income and was ready to file an affidavit to that effect. However, the bench termed the claim “impossible” and made strong observations, stating that if the husband could not pay maintenance, he should keep his wife with him so that she could cook and support herself, the children, and him.
When the husband argued that his wife had filed complaints even against his parents, Justice Mehta responded sharply, saying that arranging money for the wife’s maintenance was his responsibility and that he must find means, even if it meant borrowing or seeking help, to fulfil that obligation.
When the court spoke of summoning the company, the husband’s lawyer remarked that such a move might benefit other employees as well. After hearing the arguments, the court reserved its judgment in the matter.

As per the Bill, those involved in unlawful conversions on the pretext of marriage will be punished with imprisonment of seven years and shall also be liable for a fine of Rs 1 lakh. Violations in respect of a minor, a person of unsound mind, a woman or a person belonging to the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe will be punished with imprisonment of seven years and a fine of Rs 5 lakh.












