HR&CE Commissioner need not hear Mutt head before granting consent to file a civil suit for his removal, rules Madras High Court
The Hindu
Madras High Court rules HR&CE Commissioner can grant consent for civil suit without inquiry, ensuring no frivolous suits.
The Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) Commissioner need not conduct any kind of inquiry before granting his/her consent to a group of individuals to file a civil suit for the removal of a Madathipathi (head of a Mutt), the Madras High Court has ruled.
A Division Bench of Justices S.M. Subramaniam and K. Rajasekar agreed with Special Government Pleader N.R.R. Arun Natarajan that Section 59(1) of the HR&CE Act, 1959 does not even require the Commissioner to issue notice to the Madathipathi before granting consent.
The judges said the object behind the necessity to obtain Commissioner’s consent was only to prevent filing of a frivolous suit against any Madathipathi. Therefore, the Commissioner could either grant or reject consent based on the application filed by people interested in the Mutt concerned.
If the Commissioner refuses to grant consent, the applicants could file a statutory appeal before the government under Section 59(2) of the Act and only during the appeal proceedings, the law mandates the government to conduct an inquiry before taking a final decision, the court pointed out.
“Right of hearing or inquiry has not been contemplated under Section 59(1) of the Act. It is a decision to be taken by the Commissioner based on the application... It is the discretion of the Commissioner to conduct an inquiry, if he considers it fit, for taking an appropriate decision,” the Division Bench said.
The verdict was delivered while dismissing a writ appeal filed by Sri Sankara Subramania Dharma Siva Acharya Swamigal who was the Madathipathi of Sri Thiruvalangadu Immudi Agora Dharma Sivachariayar Arya Vysya Mutt at Nerinjipettai in Bhavani taluk of Erode district.
The appellant was aggrieved against the consent granted by the HR&CE Commissioner to seven individuals on August 5, 2016 for instituting a civil suit for the removal of the Madathipathi on being aggrieved that the latter was allegedly not attending the Mutt regularly.
Sangareddy medical college faces inquiry into ragging incident, prompting a legal awareness program on anti-ragging laws for students.
Join 20,000 attendees in Hubballi on December 13 to honor Basavaraj Horatti's 45 years of service as MLC.
NITK hosts a five-day workshop for JNV teachers, focusing on innovative pedagogy and capacity building in education.
EVM commissioning for local body elections begins in Kozhikode, covering multiple blocks and municipalities, set to complete by December 7.
Wildlife researchers capture rare photograph of Sonnerat's shrew, believed extinct for over 200 years, in the Nilgiris.
Pinarayi Vijayan criticizes ED's notice to KIIFB, pledging legal defense and emphasizing adherence to RBI guidelines for infrastructure funding.
Supreme Court rejects mercy plea of convicted 'Swami' serving life for the 1991 murder of his wife, Shakereh Khaleeli.
Telangana, Australia’s Deakin University ink pact to set up CoE for AI
Farmers protest in Kalaburagi, demanding immediate opening of maize procurement centres and a support price of ₹3,000 per quintal.
Delhi High Court affirms MHA’s 2013 policy prohibiting colour-blind recruits in CAPFs, citing safety concerns for armed forces.
BJP leader Annamalai criticizes DMK for minority appeasement and defying court orders on Karthigai Deepam at Thirupparankundram.
'Telangana doing well in Beti Bachao Beti Padhao scheme'
Join The Hindu in School Science Festival in Madikeri on December 13 for an exciting inter-school competition in science and math.