Montreal not required to pay back $1M to recycling company Ricova
CBC
Quebec's Court of Appeal has reversed a lower court's decision requiring the City of Montreal to reimburse $1 million to recycling company Ricova after the company failed to fulfill its contract with the borough of Côte-des-Neiges—Notre-Dame-de-Grâce (CDN-NDG) in 2017.
The Court of Appeal's ruling on Wednesday centers on penalties the city imposed on the recycling giant for ending its contract to collect waste in the borough.
Ricova Services Inc. obtained the contract after the city put out a call for tenders with incorrect data about the work that needed to be done — information that was soon after corrected but contributed to Ricova's inability to hold up its end of the agreement.
Ricova filed a lawsuit in 2019, seeking reimbursement in the amount of $1,014,903 for penalties it claimed were "unlawfully collected" by the city after the company ended its agreement due to an inability to fulfill its obligations.
A Quebec Superior Court judge ruled in 2024 that Montreal must reimburse Ricova because it had led the recycling company to think it would be released from its obligations once a new contract was awarded to a third-party company.
In his testimony in the lower court proceedings, Ricova president and CEO Dominic Colubriale said Montreal was told the company would go out of business if it stayed in the contract.
"The option to continue the contract wasn't really an option, because number one, we didn't have the trucks. Number two, we were going to go out of business," Colubriale said.
Shortly after the city launched a call for tenders on March 27, 2017, it noticed that it had incorrectly entered only half of the average number of loads, doors and trucks in CDN-NDG, the ruling says. The city corrected the mistake on March 30.
However, Sansfaçon found that Ricova placed a bid on a contract with the borough and calculated its pricing without taking into account the corrections.
Ricova first struggled to meet demands in the borough in December 2017.
The multinational company based on Montreal's South Shore drew ire for allowing recycling to pile up for weeks while having a contract to collect household waste and compost with many Montreal boroughs.
By February 2018, the company submitted to Montreal a notice of termination of the agreement, citing a "considerable loss of revenue."
"It is difficult for an SME (Small to Medium-sized Enterprise) to be able to endure such considerable losses in the long term," an excerpt of the notice reads. "We would certainly have liked to continue our services in the -- borough had it not been for these losses."
In 2018, CDN-NDG had fined the company more than $60,000 for allowing recycling to accumulate on streets.
Ottawa is staring down a court-ordered deadline to submit a new plan to reform the on-reserve child welfare system, as a group of First Nations leaders and children’s advocates prepare a competing proposal.
An underpass revitalization project that was meant to pay tribute to the people of Parkdale has instead deteriorated into “a garbage dump,” according to nearby residents.
A young man has been charged with criminal negligence causing bodily harm after a fire at a frat party near Western University that injured five sorority sisters, including two seriously, late Tuesday night.
The massive deal to combine one of Hollywood's oldest studios with a streaming giant hasn't even been approved yet, but it's already riling multiple related industries and politicians concerned about monopolies and media concentration.
Mi'kmaq chiefs and a former Nova Scotia justice minister are criticizing the provincial government for directing police to crack down on illegal cannabis, saying the order undermines relations with Indigenous Peoples.
For years, there has been “glaring inequity” in the way the province has allocated the millions of dollars in its county roads budget, according to Department of Transportation Minister Chuck Chiasson.
Six months after passing a law aimed at making it easier for new grocery stores to open, Manitoba's premier says lower grocery bills could be on the horizon.
Timothy Smith was acting in self-defence when he punched Landon Waddell, and shouldn't be found guilty of manslaughter, his lawyer says.
Thoroughbred horse racing at Vancouver’s Hastings Racecourse is ending after more than a century, with the operator announcing Friday it will no longer run a racing season at the historic facility.
A memorial to remember lives lost to gender-based violence was held in Charlottetown Friday, ahead of the National Day of Remembrance and Action on Violence Against Women, which is marked annually on Dec. 6.
A Calgary dentist who defrauded five insurance companies over a decade should spend up to three years in prison, the prosecution argued Friday.
B.C. Conservation Officer Service says it has called off its search for a bear responsible for an attack on a group of school children in Bella Coola, B.C. on Nov. 20.
The union president called it a rally for solidarity as Iqaluit Housing Authority employees gathered Friday while negotiations are ongoing between the Nunavut Employees Union and the employer.