Battle brews between city, Toronto Parking Authority over revenue
CBC
A battle is brewing between the City of Toronto and one of its own agencies over how to share 10s of millions of dollars in profit generated by publicly-owned parking lots.
The Toronto Parking Authority wants to keep more of the cash it makes for the city. It's warning that it will need to defer over $14 million in capital spending this year if a new profit sharing agreement isn't reached in the next few months.
Those "material cuts" could hurt the city's Bike Share and electric vehicle charging programs, the agency says.
The last agreement between the city and TPA expired in 2019 but the terms remain in effect. It requires the agency to give the city either $38 million a year or 85 per cent of the agency's profits, whichever is greater.
The Toronto Parking Authority declined an interview request by CBC Toronto. But at a recent board meeting, executives made the case for a new agreement.
"The time for that new deal is now," Jeffrey Dea, the TPA's vice president of growth and strategy, said at the March meeting.
In a report, the agency says the profit sharing arrangement, which was reached in 2017, is obsolete. It did not account for the expanded duties given to the parking authority by city council in the years since.
Those include operation of Toronto Bike Share and the expansion of its electric vehicle charging station program, programs which cost it millions. The agency says it is grappling with a $300 million state of good repair backlog for its parking lots over the next decade. It also needs to replace over 3,000 Pay & Display machines reaching the end of their life.
"The 85 per cent tax is punitive given the expanded mandate that we have," Dea said of the arrangement.
The parking authority said it has contributed $1.4 billion to the city through the dividend since 2002. That has been used to fund "other municipal services and programs, including public transit, housing and parks."
The talks come at a time when the city is struggling to address large structural deficits every year and contemplating the creation of new taxes and fees to address the gap.
The negotiations between the city and parking authority have been underway for two years. They were projected to wrap up ahead of the 2024 budget cycle earlier this year, but Dea told the board that work to address the city's $1.8 billion deficit delayed discussions.
Coun. Brad Bradford, who is a member of the TPA board, said the agency is at a "breaking point."
"The TPA simply cannot continue to deliver on the things that city council has directed them to, including electric vehicle infrastructure, and a bike share network that's expanding across the city, without retaining more of that revenue," he said.
When the New Brunswick Health Council released its report this week on avoidable deaths in the province, one area stood out.
Almost once a month for almost a year, Kathleen Toman has left her home in Balsam Lake, Ont., for Mont-Tremblant, Que. This weekend, she’ll make the 500-kilometre trip again, meeting her ex-husband, Chris Toman, there.
A charity in Chase, B.C., has secured funding that it hopes will improve child-care services in the community by training new childhood educators.
Ontario is seeking feedback on a potential amendment to the Coroners Act that may replace mandatory inquests into jail deaths with coroner-led annual reviews.
Paul Myllyniemi takes the bus to work in Thunder Bay, Ont., every day — except when it doesn’t show up.
Residents in the Greater Toronto Area are digging themselves out and going back to their regular weekday schedules a day after a major snowstorm.
Commuters hoping to escape the cold by travelling on Line 6 will need to think again, as train service is down Friday morning.
Halim Rahim has lived in Canada for almost four years, but says he’s never experienced a winter like this.
For Lindsay Gillan, walking her dog, Daisy, twice a day in Charlottetown’s Victoria Park is a treasured routine that benefits both her physical and mental health.
Whitehorse city council has postponed its decision on an overhaul of its zoning bylaws that would, among other things, introduce short-term rental regulations in the city.
Prime Minister Mark Carney says he has reached a deal with China to allow tens of thousands of Chinese electric vehicles into the country in exchange for lower canola duties.
The Federal Court of Appeal is expected to give its decision Friday morning on whether the Liberal government unlawfully invoked the Emergencies Act to clear the convoy protests that gridlocked the capital city and border points nearly four years ago.
WARNING: This article describes allegations of sexual assault.