Sleep expert believes father likely killed infant son during parasomnia episode
CBC
A psychiatrist who specializes in sleep disorders told an Edmonton second-degree murder trial Friday that the accused killer was "most likely" experiencing parasomnia when he killed his son.
Dr. Colin Shapiro said parasomnia can include things like sleep terrors, walking, talking and even driving while a person is asleep.
"The brain is still sleeping but you're functioning at some level," Shapiro said.
Damien Starrett admits that he punched his five-year-old daughter and fatally injured his one-year old son Ares on Nov. 23, 2019, but he insists he was in a sleeping, automaton-like state at the time.
His daughter's name is protected by a court-ordered publication ban. Earlier in the trial, she testified her father fell asleep on the couch and after he attacked her brother and then her, she woke him up by tickling his armpit.
"He said sorry. Then he sat on the couch," she testified.
Defence lawyer Rory Ziv asked the Toronto-based psychiatrist, who was qualified as an expert witness, what he would conclude from Starrett going back to sleep after he fatally struck his son and injured his daughter.
"I think that speaks pretty strongly to it being parasomnia," Shapiro told the court.
Shapiro said around seven per cent of the adult population experiences parasomnia, with the numbers for children much higher at 20 to 30 per cent.
Shapiro also testified people with fetal alcohol spectrum disorder (FASD) are more likely to suffer from parasomnia.
The trial has been told that Starrett has been diagnosed with FASD. He testified he has suffered from sleep problems for most of his life.
Shapiro agreed with Ziv that a number of factors Starrett was experiencing could have had a compounding effect that led to parasomnia on the day Ares died.
Starrett was stressed about his finances and relationship with his partner. He was going through heroin withdrawal, had ingested a large number of Percocets and had debilitating back pain.
"If I told you he was sleep deprived for days, would that be relevant?" Ziv asked the doctor.
The soccer world may be coming to Toronto this summer, but right now the city is just waiting for the province to show up.
With less than six weeks to go, preparations are ramping up for the 2026 Montana's Brier in St. John's — including the release of one last full batch of tickets on Tuesday at 12 p.m. NT.
Within weeks of Robinson Huron Treaty settlement money landing in people’s bank accounts, police in several northern Ontario First Nations say something else arrived too: drug traffickers, financial scammers and a surge in violent crime.
Some people who work in recycling and waste diversion say more sharps — medical needles used for injections — are ending up in Nova Scotia's waste streams and they think it's time for provincial regulations.
As Doreen Paul scrolls through photos on her phone, Bronson Paul's life flashes by.
Quebec City police have confirmed that the remains recovered from the St. Lawrence River last week are those of Susana Rocha Cruz, who had been missing since mid-January.
The Winnipeg Airports Authority wants to develop land west of Richardson International Airport to make way for a proposed WestJet maintenance facility, sources at city hall said.
Bob Behari is planning his dream project on a prime piece of land overlooking the South Saskatchewan River in Saskatoon’s Nutana neighbourhood.
Saskatchewan’s Notre Dame Hounds made an unexpected stop in Rathwell, Man., Friday night after their bus went off the road into a snowbank.
Herb Dickieson is no longer in the running to be leader of the New Democratic Party of Prince Edward Island.
A commission reviewing Alberta’s electoral boundaries suggests Edmonton should have 21 ridings — up from its current 20 — but some Edmontonians say the city should have more than that, based on the growing population.
A worsening problem with human feces in and around East Vancouver's Grandview Park became one of the reasons for B.C. resident Zoe Raffard to move out of the city permanently.
In a first step toward modernizing residential care facilities, the City of Hamilton will change the way it funds privately run, subsidized homes.