Toronto councillors consider maximum ban for contractor that overbilled city $1.1M
CBC
Toronto city councillors are set to decide the fate of a contractor that intentionally overbilled the city more than $1 million, a breach of the supplier code of conduct uncovered by a forensic audit conducted for the city.
Staff are recommending Capital Sewer Services Inc. face the maximum suspension Toronto can issue against suppliers that break the city's rules: a five-year contracting ban on it and all its affiliated companies.
In the past five years, Capital Sewer has been awarded 31 contracts by the city, totalling about $220 million.
Capital Sewer intentionally overbilled the City of Toronto $1.1 million for a sewer rehabilitation project in York Centre, according to a forensic audit by professional services firm KPMG. The KPMG forensic audit was launched in July 2025, after the city’s internal controls, as well as complaints to the auditor general’s fraud and waste hotline, found irregularities in change orders throughout 2024.
“There needs to be penalties, I absolutely support [the five-year ban],” Mayor Olivia Chow said Monday at an unrelated news conference.
The report before council says there is no dispute that the city has been overbilled by at least $1.1 million, and an ongoing audit will determine if any additional financial deception took place.
Councillors will be voting to approve the maximum suspension after David Beswick, president of the firm’s parent company, Capital Infrastructure Group, argued against its length at a city committee meeting earlier in December.
“A single, long-time trusted employee, someone who held a position of great responsibility, betrayed not only me and our company, but also the trust of you,” Beswick told the general government committee.
Beswick said that the employee's actions "do not reflect who we are or what we stand for," and he said he will ensure nothing similar happens again.
“The proposed five-year ban puts 300 jobs at risk,” said Beswick, whose company was also slapped with a five-year ban by York Region in June. The region did not respond to a CBC News request as to why Capital Sewer was banned there.
In a separate statement to CBC News, Capital Infrastructure also said it has “implemented industry-leading controls to prevent a recurrence” and is committed to full restitution to the city.
That “single, long-time trusted employee” Beswick referred to was a member of Capital Sewer’s senior management team who, through a promotion in 2022, gained administrative oversight of change orders, according to a city report.
As a result of a clause that that same senior leader negotiated, they would receive 2.25 per cent of the value of all change orders executed under their control. The person is not identified by name in the report councillors received.
“It is concerning to staff that senior management of Capital Sewer did not identify the incentive scheme as a potential for fraud,” the report says.
Members of the Jewish community in Waterloo in southern Ontario celebrated the first night of Hanukkah on Sunday by lighting a massive five-metre-high menorah.
Charlottetown residents now have a new tool to help them follow the progress P.E.I.’s capital is making on its climate action plan.
The Northwest Territories’ minister of Industry, Tourism and Investment (ITI) says government presence at mining conferences is “critically important” after she and two other territorial delegates travelled to London, England, for five days earlier this month to attend Resourcing Tomorrow.
Conservative MP Jamil Jivani says he's ready to lend a hand and do what he can, if Prime Minister Mark Carney says he wants help restarting trade negotiations with the United States.
The Carney government is making good on a promise to help tackle one of the most potent forms of climate pollution, as it announces new measures to address methane emissions from the oil and gas industry.
Tracey Nicholson cried tears of joy when her 11-year wait for social housing in Kington, Ont., finally ended with an apartment at 381 Bagot St.
Toronto city councillors are set to decide the fate of a contractor that intentionally overbilled the city more than $1 million, a breach of the supplier code of conduct uncovered by a forensic audit conducted for the city.
A 29-year-old registered massage therapist has been accused by London police of sexually assaulting a client, and investigators say they believe there may be other victims.
A mass shooting in which 15 people were killed during a Hanukkah celebration at Sydney's Bondi Beach was "a terrorist attack inspired by Islamic State," Australia's federal police commissioner Krissy Barrett said Tuesday.
A three-man committee will lead Newfoundland and Labrador's independent review of the Churchill Falls memorandum of understanding with Quebec, and it has four months to do it.
A Yarmouth, N.S., woman has pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the 2020 death of her 17-month-old son.
A new agreement signed between Parks Canada and eight Mi'kmaq First Nations in New Brunswick will give the Mi'kmaq a hand in the management of national parks and historic sites.
A Quebec teachers' union released the findings of a survey of its members on Monday that found 90 per cent of respondents said they were victims of some form of violence at work.