Top court asked to allow challenge of decision clearing Trudeau of ethics breach in WE Charity controversy
CBC
Canada's top court is hearing final arguments on Thursday in a case resurfacing former prime minister Justin Trudeau's role in the WE Charity scandal, which could bring sweeping changes to how Canadians hold their elected officials accountable.
The Supreme Court of Canada is wrapping up two days of hearings after Democracy Watch challenged a 2021 decision by the federal ethics commissioner that cleared Trudeau of a conflict of interest.
That ethics finding stemmed from the Liberal government's decision to give WE Charity a $43-million contract to run a $912-million student grant program amid family connections Trudeau and then finance minister Bill Morneau had with the organization.
Former ethics commissioner Mario Dion found Morneau breached the Conflict of Interest Act when he failed to recuse himself from cabinet deliberations on the contract, but concluded Trudeau did not.
Duff Conacher, co-founder of Democracy Watch, wants the opportunity to try to overturn Dion's decision in the Federal Court of Appeal.
"That only should make the ethics commissioner function better," Conacher told CBC News.
"If the ethics commissioner can't be challenged in court, you have a closed loop where the ruling party cabinet chooses their own watchdog and then that watchdog's an unaccountable czar who can protect the people who give them the job," he said, reflecting the argument his group is making to the Supreme Court.
Since Trudeau is no longer prime minister, several Supreme Court justices suggested on Wednesday that the appeal court could find the case moot. But Democracy Watch is arguing Dion's decision should be reviewed on principle for future ethical issues that could arise.
"It would exponentially increase government, federal government ethics standards," Conacher said.
If Conacher's advocacy group wins, the decision would not only force a review of Dion's 2021 Trudeau WE Charity finding. Its far-reaching implications would include opening the door to allow any watchdog decision to be challenged in court.
"It's clarifying the extent to which the court can watch [the watchdog] effectively," said Brandon Barnes Trickett, partner in public law litigation practice at Dentons Canada in Toronto.
But he said that in exchange for increased accountability, there would be an increase in administrative burden, costs and the timeliness of delivering justice.
"That's the eternal balancing act in which Parliament and these decision-makers and the public are all engaged: How much justice and how much accountability and how much thoroughness and how much expertise can we afford?" Barnes Trickett said.
The case was brought to the high court after the Federal Court of Appeal dismissed Democracy Watch's initial request for judicial review. The court said accountability through the Conflict of Interest Act mainly rests with Parliament. Democracy Watch appealed.
Homicide investigators have identified the victim of a fatal Surrey, B.C., house fire on Monday.
The number of homeless encampments has declined across Toronto in the past year, according to city officials, but at least one advocate says the city has simply moved unhoused people out of sight.
One of North America’s largest caribou herds — known for its over 2,400-kilometre migration across Arctic tundra, snow-covered mountains and roaring rivers to its calving grounds on Alaska’s coastal plain — is declining.
The Liberal Party is calling on the P.E.I. government to add more long-term care beds to help hospitals across the province that are dealing with overcrowding issues.
A week after an independent panel presented a review that pointed to failings within Calgary’s water system, the provincial government has announced it will do its own review of the system.
Just weeks after Yukoners pleaded with Mother Nature to ease off the extreme cold, travel was snarled across the southern part of the territory thanks to unseasonably warm weather.
The London region is in for another blast of winter weather Wednesday afternoon.
Some of Sharon Woynarski's neighbours describe her as relentless and tenacious.
Quebec Premier François Legault is expected to step down at a news conference at 11 a.m., according to Radio-Canada sources.
A Newfoundland and Labrador Supreme Court justice has dismissed an application requesting a review of a decision that cleared a former police officer of discreditable conduct.
Ontario’s Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks is aiming to reopen at least part of Samuel de Champlain Provincial Park in the spring.
The new board members of the Africville Genealogy Society are sharing their vision for the historic Black community after being elected last fall.
Large industrial companies in New Brunswick are making a push to exit the N.B. Power grid and generate their own renewable electricity in a move the utility says could leave other ratepayers facing higher bills.