Suspended Vancouver lawyer's lawsuit dismissed as abuse of process with pseudolegal hallmarks
CBC
A lawsuit filed by a suspended Vancouver lawyer against her neighbour has been dismissed by a B.C. Supreme Court associate judge, who described it as "frivolous and vexatious" and bearing many hallmarks of a pseudolegal claim.
The resolution to what experts have described as a highly unusual and troubling case came Friday morning, when B.C. Supreme Court Associate Judge Susanna Hughes handed down her judgment in Naomi Arbabi's claim of "trespass" against her neighbour Colleen McLelland.
Arbabi had alleged that McLelland trespassed upon her by obstructing her mountain view when the strata of their Fairview condo building installed a 1.7 metre-high glass divider privacy divider on McLelland's rooftop deck.
Hughes wrote that Arbabi's claim doesn't have a reasonable legal basis. She said it also bears "many of the hallmarks of claims made by OPCA [Organized Pseudolegal Commercial Arguments] litigants" — a thoroughly debunked and wholly unsuccessful class of legal theory favoured by fringe groups like Sovereign Citizens and Freemen on the Land.
"It is frivolous and vexatious insofar as it denies the authority of the court," Hughes wrote.
"It is an abuse of process insofar as the plaintiff has filed her initiating document as an attempt not to litigate legitimately in this court, but instead to utilize this court's infrastructure for the purposes of her fictional court."
In Arbabi's notice of claim, filed on Oct. 5, she identifies herself as "i, a woman" and says the case would be tried in the "naomi arbabi court."
Arbabi wrote that "this is a claim based on law of the land, and not a complaint based on legal codes acts or statutes" and asks for compensation equal to $1,000 a day for every day the glass divider has been in place — adding up to more than $130,000 by now.
When she appeared in court in November to fight McLelland's application to dismiss her claim, Arbabi said she was appearing as "a living, breathing, alive woman," not a lawyer, and denied any association with organized pseudolegal groups.
Hughes pointed to several areas where Arbabi's arguments match those of OPCA litigants, as laid out in the landmark 2012 Meads vs. Meads decision from Alberta. That includes the use of a double or split person strategy wherein she calls herself "the woman: naomi arbabi" rather than Naomi Arbabi; her attempt to establish a "naomi arbabi court"; and her apparent denial of the court's jurisdiction over her.
Hughes has also ordered Arbabi to pay special costs to McLelland for breaching a professional oath promising lawyers "will not promote suits upon frivolous pretences."
In dismissing the claim, the associate judge also said the court doesn't have jurisdiction to hear claims like this, which should properly go to the Civil Resolution Tribunal.
At the time she filed the lawsuit and during her November court appearance, Arbabi was a lawyer in good standing with the Law Society of B.C. But her licence to practise law was suspended on an interim basis at the end of December, after an interim action board of the law society determined extraordinary action was necessary to protect the public.
CBC has reached out to Arbabi for comment on the judgment.
The Agricultural Producers Association of Saskatchewan (APAS) found some reasons to celebrate the 2026-27 provincial budget, but it takes issue with the amount designated for the province's Water Security Agency (WSA).
The family of an Edmonton woman who died in Honolulu last year is pushing for Hawaiian authorities to re-open the case.
It was around this time in 2020 that everything changed.
With its emergency shelter beds frequently running at 50 per cent over capacity and demand so great that it's forced to refer some women escaping domestic violence elsewhere, Gillian's Place in St. Catharines will soon be able to offer a broader range of services to more victims of gender-based violence.
The ceiling of the CAW Student Centre at the University of Windsor is decorated by flags of numerous nations — among them, Iran.
Turmoil in Iran, a major disruption in world oil markets, and stratospheric gasoline prices in Canada and beyond. What's racking motorists and governments in 2026 also faced them in 1979, sparked by the Iranian Revolution.
Five decades later, and Thunder Bay's Music World Academy remains a family-run business.
Dalton Dubois of Guelph, Ont., made history at the recent Paris Fashion Week when she became the first transgender model to walk the runway for Chanel Exclusive.
Work is scheduled to begin over the summer at the site of the former Clinton Creek asbestos mine, about 65 kilometres northwest of Dawson City, Yukon.
They may be bitter rivals in the House of Commons, but outside the chamber, recent events may have led to Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre and Prime Minister Mark Carney forging a bond.
Local fans and industry insiders say the province’s move to ban the reselling of event tickets for more than their original value is a step in the right direction, but some say there are still larger issues that need to be addressed.
This First Person column is the experience of Mehdi M. Kashani, who lives in Toronto. For more information about CBC's First Person stories, please see the FAQ.
A very quiet queue has formed in Europe where some of Canada's long-standing, closest allies are seeking shelter under France's small but robust nuclear umbrella.