Rocco the dog to be returned to late owner's family after Ontario judge rejects girlfriend's stay request
CBC
The future of Rocco Jr. is a bit more clear today after an Ontario judge ruled against the girlfriend of the dog's late owner, requiring her to hand over the animal to her deceased partner's family.
The two-year-old bull terrier has been at the centre of a legal tussle between the estate of Leonard Carvalho, who died suddenly in 2022, and his girlfriend, Aliesha Verma, who argues she is now the dog's rightful owner.
Last month, a court sided with Carvalho's family and ordered Verma to hand the dog over by March 15.
Verma's lawyer, Miranda Desa, tried to overturn that order at the Ontario Court of Appeal yesterday, but was unsuccessful.
"(Verma) is processing this, she's deciding what she wants to do next and figuring out a game plan," Desa said after the ruling. "I know she's in a difficult place."
Rocco Jr.'s story began in February 2022, when Verma and Carvalho brought the dog back from Florida after a vacation.
According to court documents, Verma has maintained that Carvalho gave the dog to her as a gift.
The day after Carvalho's sudden death in November 2022, Verma went to his house and retrieved the dog, who has lived with her ever since. Verma says Rocco Jr. is both a companion and an emotional support animal that helps her cope with ongoing emotional issues.
In a February ruling, an Ontario judge found there was no evidence Carvalho ever gave Rocco Jr. to Verma as a gift as she had claimed. The ruling gave Verma until March 15 to return Rocco Jr. to Carvalho's family.
At Thursday's hearing, Desa argued that the handover order should be stayed — at least until her appeal is heard — on the grounds that Verma should have been considered a co-owner of the dog all along.
Justice Katherine van Rensburg rejected that argument and said she will issue her reasons in writing at a future date.
Desa has said Verma plans to appeal, but isn't sure yet if yesterday's ruling will impact that decision. No date has been set for the appeal.
"This is a difficult day for Aliesha," Desa said Thursday. "She is dealing with the decision and has to make some decisions about what she wants to do moving forward."
Carvalho's lawyer, Tanya Pagliaroli, said earlier this week that the family won't be commenting on the case while it's still before the courts.
This summer, approximately 65,000 soccer fans will swarm the city’s waterfront to cheer at Toronto Stadium and the Fort York fan festival, but with only three months to go, the TTC has yet to paint a clear picture of how it will handle the stream of visitors.
It seems like everything costs more these days, and chocolate is no exception.
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith is seeking security clearance to receive briefings on foreign interference in her province, but the leader of the Opposition says she shouldn't be trusted with it.
Big dogs are loyal canines, affectionate and sweet, but often overlooked when it comes to pet adoption, according to a city agency.
In advance of what is expected to be a hot summer, the City of Kamloops is encouraging homeowners to request a free assessment of their properties to make sure they are resilient in the face of wildfire.
The proportion of hours worked by Indigenous and northern workers on the Giant Mine Remediation Project has dropped over the last few years, according to figures provided to Yellowknife city council this week.
City officials say Calgary's water usage was once again above the recommended threshold of 500 million litres on Wednesday, after two consecutive days of landing in the "green zone."
Emergency crews are on the scene of a mudslide in Coquitlam, B.C., that knocked out power for about 5,000 customers on Thursday.
Calls for the judge in the Umar Zameer case to apologize for suggesting three Toronto police officers colluded and lied in the high-profile criminal trial are "unethical" and "inappropriate," Geoffrey Morawetz, the chief justice of the Ontario Superior Court, said Thursday.
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre sat down for a more than two-hour-long interview on The Joe Rogan Experience this week.
Brandon Tobin killed his grandmother after a drug-induced seizure. A judge will soon decide his fate
A sheet of white paper shook in Brandon Tobin's hands as he read aloud his message to the judge on Thursday morning.
City officials in Greater Sudbury say crews are working day and night on cleanup efforts after a historic snowstorm buried roads, sidewalks and laneways — but residents should expect disruptions to last for weeks.
Three people were hurt and one was airlifted to a Halifax hospital with serious injuries after a crash Thursday morning on a busy highway in Cape Breton Regional Municipality.