Ontario Legislature approves rare warrant for Laurentian University financial documents

The Ontario Legislature passed a motion Thursday afternoon to issue a Speaker's warrant that would force Laurentian University to hand over documents related to its insolvency.

During the debate in the legislature, Government House Leader Paul Calandra said the Sudbury university's "utter disrespect for Parliament and the people of Ontario is shameful, and we will not let it stand."

With the warrant, Laurentian will need to give the Standing Committee on Public Accounts documents, including privileged information, related to its insolvency in February. 

Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill MPP Michael Parsa, a member of the committee, said Laurentian was given many opportunities to comply with requests for documents, and challenged the committee numerous times.

"Suffice it to say the committee gave Laurentian every opportunity to explain themselves and to comply" he said.

Parsa said the committee received a "deeply concerning" response from Laurentian on Nov. 10, in which the university said it did not have to hand over documents subject to solicitor-client privilege to an "entity that is not part of government."

But Parsa said Parliament is the "highest court in the land" and that there is past precedent for compelling documents that fall under solicitor-client privilege. 

Sudbury MPP Jamie West said he was saddened by the news of Laurentian's insolvency, and shared stories from some of the 200 workers who lost their jobs when the university cut more than 30 programs in April.

He supported the motion for a warrant to obtain the university's documents. 

Nickel Belt MPP France Gélinas, also called for her colleagues to support the motion. 

"We did not want to come here, but today we're left with no choice but to ask each MPP in this house to vote in favour of a warrant." 

The Speaker's warrant follows a legal battle between Laurentian and Ontario Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk, who has requested the university's privileged documents for a value-for-money audit.

Lysyk has argued Laurentian has been the least transparent institution she has dealt with during her time as auditor general.

In a court hearing on Monday, an Ontario Superior Court judge heard from both sides and reserved his decision as to whether Lysyk should have access to Laurentian's privileged documents.