Ontario court tosses out developer's $300K lawsuit trying to 'silence' student
CBC
The Ontario Superior Court of Justice has dismissed a $300,000 lawsuit filed by a developer against an engineering student for trying to "silence" his concerns about the redevelopment of a Mississauga, Ont., mall and plans to build adjacent residential towers.
Sheridan Retail Inc., a subsidiary of Dunpar Homes, filed the lawsuit against Pierre Roy alleging defamation and trespassing on the same day the City of Mississauga rejected its proposal for two 15-storey condominium or apartment buildings on the land surrounding Sheridan Mall in December 2023.
"It was a very stressful situation to figure out what to do," Roy said in an interview on CBC's Metro Morning. "Particularly in the middle of one of my final terms of school."
Roy had voiced concerns about the environmental sustainability and housing affordability of the developer's proposal at community consultation meetings.
He also took photos of construction work underway at the mall — which first opened in 1969 — and reported his safety concerns to the city, which investigated and found the developer had failed to obtain building permits, according to the court decision, which was released on Tuesday.
Justice Renu Mandhane ordered the developer to pay Roy $25,000 in damages and to cover all of the University of Waterloo student's legal costs.
"By claiming damages of $300,000, the developer clearly sought to intimidate a 24-year-old university student and local resident into silence," the judge wrote in her scathing decision.
"Substantial damages are warranted because the developer caused harm to the student by publicly ridiculing and belittling him and his family, threatening him with spurious legal action to silence him in advance of city council's vote, adopting heavy-handed litigation tactics, and chilling his continued public expression about the mall redevelopment project."
The lawsuit was dismissed under Ontario's anti-SLAPP legislation, which stands for "strategic lawsuits against public participation." The province introduced the legislation in 2015 to prevent the courts from being used for gag proceedings to silence freedom of expression in the public interest.
In response to Roy's motion to dismiss the lawsuit, Sheridan Retail conceded that Roy was engaging in public expression, but the developer asked the court to allow it to proceed with the lawsuit by limiting it to the trespassing claim.
But Mandhane said granting the request would be "tantamount to sanctioning its continued use of the legal system to silence the student."
"While the developer tries to cast the student as 'obsessive,' I think the more appropriate word is engaged," the judge wrote.
"The student raised safety concerns that were investigated by the city and required the developer to make changes to the construction site. The student raised concerns about housing affordability and environmental sustainability — social issues that are immensely important to young people and clearly worthy of serious public debate."
In an emailed statement, Sheridan Retail told CBC Toronto that the company has serious concerns with the decision, which it believes "was wrong on both fact and law," and will be taking its case to the Ontario Court of Appeal.
The City of Charlottetown is considering adding three apartment buildings along Mount Edward Road near the city’s bypass highway.
A new Alberta government pilot project is hoping to address a common challenge facing citizens accessing health care in a city that straddles two provinces.
The Victoria Police Department will have officers patrolling on foot for the first time since 2022, thanks to new funding from the city.
ArcelorMittal Dofasco has quietly extended its timeline by 22 years to phase out coal for "decarbonized" steelmaking, says a federal government document, aiming for 2050 instead of 2028.
In a week where President Donald Trump says the U.S. doesn’t need cars made in Canada, the Dodge Charger Sixpack — made in Windsor, Ont. — is in the running to win car of the year at the North American International Auto Show in Detroit this morning.
An Ontario man has reached a settlement agreement with Boeing almost seven years after six of his family members died in a plane crash.
Severe weather has lead to several highway closures across northern Ontario Wednesday morning.
Several Durham police officers diagnosed with post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) say they believe the service isolated them from the day they went on mental health leave and has not provided them any meaningful support.
The City of Toronto’s 2026 budget offers relief many homeowners were looking for in its property tax increase, but it also lays bare the massive amount of infrastructure work hanging over the city in the coming years which, in some cases, may be deferred.
The University of Guelph says it is offering assistance to help students stranded in Iran after a petition was started asking for more to be done by the school.
There may be some relief in sight this flu season — though it may not feel like it right now.
Students will be back in class on Wednesday morning at Robert Service School in Dawson City.
The Canadian Armed Forces would need to buy 72 Gripen fighter jets and six GlobalEye surveillance aircraft for Swedish manufacturer Saab to deliver on its pledge of creating 12,600 jobs in Canada, CBC News has learned.