KPMG wants CRA affidavit in tax 'sham' case struck from public record
CBC
In a court hearing last April, a judge agreed to restrict public access to documents in a $37-million tax "sham" case.
KPMG Law requested the temporary sealing order in the case regarding its client Gold Line Telemanagement, which the Canada Revenue Agency alleges was involved in a "carousel scheme."
Now, The Fifth Estate has learned that KPMG has applied to the court to have the affidavit at issue struck from the record completely — preventing the public from ever knowing what was in that CRA document and accompanying exhibits filed with the court last February by the Department of Justice.
While the contents of those documents are so far unknown to the public, they could provide key information regarding how an alleged $37-million tax scheme was perpetrated against the Canadian Treasury.
A media lawyer hired by CBC, Iain MacKinnon, has been granted standing to argue against KPMG's motion to strike in a court hearing scheduled for January 2024.
There can be legitimate reasons for a court to remove or seal documents in court cases. For example, courts may move to protect sensitive commercial information not relevant to the public interest.
Still, MacKinnon says Canadians have a constitutional right to access court proceedings and that motions to strike and sealing orders should be an exception.
"There's allegations that there are tens of millions of taxpayer dollars at issue," MacKinnon said. "All the evidence that is before the court should be accessible to reporters and the public."
Founded in 1991, Gold Line Telemanagement is a Canadian telecommunications company that says it researches, develops and markets telecommunications products.
Gold Line declined to answer questions from The Fifth Estate, stating the case was before the courts.
A carousel scheme refers to a group of companies working together to set up fake business transactions in order to generate illegitimate GST or HST tax refunds — when no tax was ever paid in the first place.
In a statement, the CRA said it has identified at least $1.1 billion related to carousel schemes in Canada since 2017.
The Fifth Estate reported last week on another alleged carousel scheme in Canada involving a company called Iris Technologies. In that case the CRA released $63 million in tax refunds that it is now seeking to recoup, stating they were "illegitimate."
Iris and Gold Line have both denied the allegations and appealed the CRA's reassessment to the Tax Court of Canada.
Mitchell Rose, the 32-year-old man charged with three counts of attempted murder in St. John’s, will spend the next month on the forensic unit of a psychiatric hospital.
Nearly eight years after Halifax sold the historic Khyber building in the hopes it could be revived, the municipality says the site has become a “threat to safety” — and is taking it back.
The New Brunswick government has a strategy for reducing chronic homelessness in the province by 40 per cent over the next three years, Housing Minister David Hickey said Thursday.
Quebec Health Minister Christian Dubé is stepping down.
A Winnipeg mother whose kids attend Winnipeg School Division schools says officials waited too long to let parents know classes would be cancelled on Thursday amid a winter blizzard that created dangerous road conditions across the city.
After one day of calm, Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC) says a second Alberta clipper storm will begin to hit western Saskatchewan early Friday morning.
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith's government is increasing how much it costs to apply for a citizen-initiated referendum by 5,000 per cent, saying it's about making sure applicants are serious.
A special unit established to solve cold cases of missing and murdered Indigenous people has solved the murder of a B.C. man in Washington State nearly a decade ago.
A judge ruled Thursday to remove an injunction in place since the summer against Alberta's law prohibiting doctors from providing gender-affirming care to youth.
A pedestrian is dead and another is in life-threatening condition after two vehicles collided in Richmond Hill on Thursday, striking three people, police say.
A Pelly Crossing, Yukon, resident said he's frustrated over the fact he's still waiting to get paid for work he did during last month's territorial election.
A few days after Michael Ma decided to cross the floor to the Liberals, Pierre Poilievre was asked whether the loss of another MP was a problem for his leadership of the Conservative Party.
Ontario released a new curriculum for kindergarten in the province on Thursday, but the shift away from “play-based” learning towards “academic rigor” is sparking concern from teachers and opposition.