Judge fully dismisses U.S. lawsuit against N.B.'s Cooke Inc.
CBC
A federal judge in New York has found the arguments made in a lawsuit against a large New Brunswick seafood company to be false and ordered the case closed.
Saint John-based Cooke Inc. was sued last July for its involvement in the menhaden fishery in Virginia. The lawsuit alleged Cooke knowingly defrauded the U.S. government by creating shell companies to operate the fishery of a small baitfish used to make fishmeal, fish oil and other products.
U.S. District Court Judge Jesse M. Furman dismissed the case because he found that not only did the plaintiffs not prove foreign ownership beyond a doubt, but also that the fish and fishing licences that Cooke was allegedly defrauding the government of cannot legally be considered property.
"Cooke Inc. is pleased that the court has dismissed this baseless lawsuit, which we have always maintained was without merit," Joel Richardson, company spokesperson, wrote in an emailed statement on behalf of Cooke Inc. and Omega Protein.
"For over a decade, the individuals behind this lawsuit have repeatedly targeted menhaden harvesters and processors to undermine a sustainable and essential sector of the fishing industry."
It was filed by Chris Manthey of New York and W. Chiles Benson of New Jersey as a qui tam lawsuit, which allows private citizens to file a case on behalf of the U.S. government as whistleblowers under the U.S. False Claims Act.
The lawsuit described Manthey as a "professional investigator and researcher" and Benson as someone working in the fisheries management industry who "occasionally receives non-public information" about fishing companies, including Cooke and Omega.
The premise of the lawsuit was based around Cooke-affiliated companies operating a menhaden fishery in Chesapeake Bay.
Cooke has owned Omega Protein in Virginia since 2017. Omega is affiliated with another company that operates the menhaden fishery.
The lawsuit alleged Cooke was violating the American Fisheries Act, which requires 75 per cent of a company fishing in the U.S. to be owned by a U.S. citizen.
The lawsuit also alleged that the total value Omega had fished while "falsely certifying compliance" with U.S. citizenship laws exceeded $2 billion between 2017, when Cooke bought it, and 2021, when the lawsuit was launched.
The lawsuit said the alleged scheme was accomplished through a restructuring of Omega after the 2017 purchase by transferring Omega vessels to another company, Ocean Harvesters.
That company was then sold to a shell company called Alpha VesselCo, operating as Ocean Fleet Services, in Delaware, which the lawsuit said is 20 per cent owned by Omega and 80 per cent owned by U.S. citizen Seth Dunlop. The lawsuit claimed Dunlop was "a figurehead," a longtime Cooke employee and nephew of Cooke CEO Glenn Cooke.
Cooke Inc., Cooke Aquaculture, Omega Protein, Ocean Harvesters, Ocean Fleet Services and Dunlop were named in the suit.
The NDP leadership race could be turning into a nail-biter with no clear winner in sight. But it's unclear if Canadians are tuning in.
As the prime minister gears up to visit China, his parliamentary secretary, MP Kody Blois, says Mark Carney would like to "recalibrate" Canada's once-frosty relationship with the Chinese government and look at economic opportunities for the two nations.
Ontario appears set to push ahead with a ban on declawing cats and debarking and ear cropping dogs, a move animal welfare advocates say is years overdue and doesn’t go far enough.
If you’ve ever wanted to groove to music while drinking coffee, the Kitchener Downtown BIA has you covered this winter.
Iranian Montrealers rallied in the downtown core Saturday afternoon in a show of support for the people of Iran.
A Manitoba judge says Natural Resources Minister Ian Bushie must reconsider granting permits to a company that's no longer allowed to take tourists to see polar bears in large tundra vehicles east of Churchill.
Some people from a northern Saskatchewan reserve were left without phone landline and internet services for weeks, and wonder why it took so long for SaskTel to address the issue.
Alberta’s rate cap is deepening financial losses in the province's auto insurance market, industry experts say, as a new report found auto insurers lost more than $1.2 billion in 2024.
Environment and Climate Change Canada says an atmospheric river will take aim at British Columbia's south coast this weekend as heavy rain continues to batter the north coast.
Islanders packed into the temporary location for the Charlottetown Farmers' Market Saturday, marking the first day operating on North River Road in the former Sporting Intentions space.
More than 1,000 demonstrators gathered in Richmond Hill, Ont., Saturday to show solidarity to protesters in Iran, fighting against the country’s financial collapse and the regime that led to it.
The City of Toronto began its first pothole repair blitz of the year Friday with crews working to fill potholes across the city overnight and into Saturday.
One of the best gifts Cameron Eckert got for Christmas was a sighting of four white-tailed ptarmigan.