Judge certifies class-action lawsuit over delayed bail hearings and alleged Charter breaches
CBC
A class-action lawsuit alleging that the Alberta government breached Charter rights potentially thousands of times by denying people timely bail hearings will go ahead.
In a decision filed in Calgary on Monday, Court King's Bench Associate Chief Justice John Rooke certified a class-action suit for individuals arrested between May 2, 2016, and Sept. 26, 2022, who were caught up in what the plaintiffs allege was a systemic breach of the province's bail system.
At issue is the Criminal Code requirement of a right to a bail hearing within 24 hours of being arrested.
The plaintiffs allege that when the province changed how it runs first-appearance bail hearings in late 2016, many people were held in custody for longer than they should have been.
"The government has overall responsibility for the criminal justice system," one of the lawyers for the plaintiffs Margaret Waddell said in an interview Tuesday.
"If there's a presumption of innocence you shouldn't be incarcerated unless there's good reason to hold you."
Waddell said they have to wait for the province to disclose how many "overholds" – being held beyond 24 hours without a bail hearing – occurred within the period identified in the lawsuit, but it is expected to be a significant number.
According to provincial data highlighted in Rooke's decision, between March 2018 and June 2020 nearly 17,000 people were subject to overholds, which amounts to about 12 per cent of all arrestees.
Waddell said qualified class members are those who would have been released had they had a timely bail hearing or those who were ultimately acquitted.
She added that it's her understanding that overholds decreased significantly in 2020.
To proceed to a trial, a class action must be certified by a judge who finds certain criteria has been met.
Lawyers for the provincial government opposed the certification on several grounds, including that the justice minister can't micromanage police agencies responsible for arranging bail hearings, and that the lawsuit doesn't address the cause of the delay.
Rooke rejected that argument.
"It is the fact of delay beyond 24 hours, not the individual causes or who caused the delay that is relevant to certification," he wrote.
The RCMP has not recruited enough new officers or effectively assigned its members to meet its operational needs, according to a new report from the auditor general — raising concerns about public safety across the country.
Oil prices fell Monday morning after President Donald Trump said the U.S. would hold off on striking Iran’s energy infrastructure amid productive talks between the two countries.
Premier Doug Ford says his government plans to give Toronto's Billy Bishop Airport special designation that would allow the province to bypass municipal and provincial laws as it pushes to expand the runway downtown.
Jenelle Hughes says she worries every time her two older children take their car to get to Fanshawe College in London, Ont., from their home in Dutton.
Oil prices fell Monday morning after President Donald Trump said the U.S. would hold off on striking Iran’s energy infrastructure amid productive talks between the two countries.
While spring technically started late last week, Newfoundland and Labrador isn't free from winter weather just yet.
The Sudbury School Bus Consortium is suspending all school buses in Greater Sudbury as the community continues to clean up following a major storm.
Two large corporate landlords owning a combined 9,008 rental units in Halifax are reporting smaller annual increases in their average rents for 2025 than the previous year.
The Holt government has reached a deal with Ottawa on compensation for tens of millions of dollars in lost sales tax revenue from the Christmas season in 2024.
The government of Saskatchewan has announced plans to reduce the length of non-resident game bird hunting licences to combat illegal guiding.
An 87-year-old Alberta man is fighting extradition to the United Kingdom to stand trial for historical allegations of physical and sexual assault involving minors.
Eight casinos across southwest B.C. have been sold to First Nations in the last two years, with the province's gambling scene set to be reshaped as a result.
Hamilton hosts the Junos Sunday, and the musical awards show is bringing tourists, musicians, concerts and a ton of themed events to the city this week.