Intelligence watchdog questions cyber agency's approach to international law, CSE insists it was above board
CBC
One of Canada's intelligence watchdogs has scolded the country's cyber security agency over its approach to international law.
The National Security and Intelligence Review Agency reviewed the Communications Security Establishment's activities in 2019, the first year after it received new powers. While the review was completed in 2020, its report was made public only this week.
The CSE insists it never violated international law and is calling the matter a "philosophical" disagreement with its oversight body.
"CSE, because we are the ones who deal with foreign cyber operations, did not violate international law. We did not even come close to violating international law," Nabih Eldebs, CSE deputy chief of authorities, compliance and transparency, told CBC News.
"This was not in our ethos, this was not in our thinking."
CSE is empowered to gather foreign signals intelligence and defend Canada's national security, including government of Canada servers and networks. It also has a growing role in protecting Canada's critical infrastructure, such as banks, telecommunications and the energy industry.
To do all that, the agency was granted the ability in 2018 — with ministerial consent — to launch "active cyber operations" to disrupt threats from terrorist groups, hostile intelligence agencies and state-sponsored hackers.
As an example of what this power allows it to do, CSE says it can prevent a foreign terrorist group from communicating or planning attacks by disabling their communication devices.
In its report, NSIRA wrote that when it asked CSE to explain its legal obligations when launching such operations, the agency's response was lacking.
"CSE has not sufficiently examined its obligations under international law," said the intelligence review body in its heavily redacted report.
Eldebs said the federal government was still developing its official stance on cyberspace and international law as CSE was beginning to launch these operations.
"These were our new foray into foreign cyber operations," he said.
"I think, in my belief, it was a philosophical disagreement on the approach to international law between both organizations, not the importance of international law."
The government of Canada released a public statement on international law applicable to cyber space in 2021. Eldebs said the CSE now uses that statement as a guiding principle.
Six months after passing a law aimed at making it easier for new grocery stores to open, Manitoba's premier says lower grocery bills could be on the horizon.
Timothy Smith was acting in self-defence when he punched Landon Waddell, and shouldn't be found guilty of manslaughter, his lawyer says.
Thoroughbred horse racing at Vancouver’s Hastings Racecourse is ending after more than a century, with the operator announcing Friday it will no longer run a racing season at the historic facility.
A memorial to remember lives lost to gender-based violence was held in Charlottetown Friday, ahead of the National Day of Remembrance and Action on Violence Against Women, which is marked annually on Dec. 6.
A Calgary dentist who defrauded five insurance companies over a decade should spend up to three years in prison, the prosecution argued Friday.
B.C. Conservation Officer Service says it has called off its search for a bear responsible for an attack on a group of school children in Bella Coola, B.C. on Nov. 20.
The union president called it a rally for solidarity as Iqaluit Housing Authority employees gathered Friday while negotiations are ongoing between the Nunavut Employees Union and the employer.
The federal government is stoking Quebec separatism by walking back its climate commitments — including in its recent deal with Alberta — Liberal MP and former cabinet minister Steven Guilbeault says.
Four more Alberta MLAs are facing recall petitions organized by their constituents, including the first NDP representative to be caught in the province's ongoing wave of recall efforts.
Frank Gehry, the Canadian-born renegade architect behind some of the world's most recognizable buildings, has died at 96.
Hundreds of P.E.I. parents can't find child-care spaces, especially for infants. The provincial government says expanding those spots remains a top priority — and it recognizes the concern.
An Alberta judge says a referendum proposal on Alberta separating from Canada goes against Charter and and Treaty rights, in a decision given less than 24 hours after the provincial government introduced legislation that would have ended the court proceeding.
The architect of Alberta's politician recall legislation says it was never meant to be used as a political weapon, but as an "ultimate tool of accountability" if a politician engages in illegal or unethical behaviour.