'Failure of reconciliation': First Nations slam Yukon gov't for taking assessment board to court
CBC
Two Yukon First Nations slammed the territorial government in court Thursday for taking legal action after an assessment office recommended against a mineral exploration project in the Peel watershed.
Lawyers representing Tr'ondëk Hwëch'in (TH) and the First Nation of Na-Cho Nyäk Dun (FNNND) asked a Yukon Supreme Court judge Thursday to toss the case, arguing it was baseless.
"Why are we here?" TH lawyer Micah Clark asked.
FNNND lawyer Tasha Paramalingam, meanwhile, said the government taking the issue to court instead of consulting with First Nations was a "failure of reconciliation" and shouldn't have happened in the first place.
Clark and Paramalingam's submissions came on the second of a three-day hearing of a legal petition filed by the territorial government last year against the Yukon Environmental and Socio-economic Assessment Board (YESAB).
The government filed the petition after the board's Dawson-area designated office recommended against allowing an exploration project to proceed in the southern edge of the Peel watershed.
Company Silver47 had proposed to do five years of work in the Michelle Creek area, near the northern tip of Tombstone Territorial Park. The office, in its recommendation, cited adverse effects to wildlife and First Nations wellness that could not be mitigated. It also noted the proposal did not conform with the Peel Watershed Regional Land Use Plan because the company did not provide baseline data on wildlife.
The Yukon government and Silver47, earlier in the hearing, argued that the recommendation was "unreasonable" and asked for a court order that the assessment be re-done.
Paramalingam, in her submissions, said that the Yukon didn't have standing to take legal action in the first place, arguing that the recommendation didn't substantively impact the Yukon as it was non-binding and the government remained a decision-makers on whether the project would proceed.
She also argued the Yukon could have rectified any issues it had with the recommendation through processes outside of court, including consulting with First Nations on next steps. Both FNNND and TH, she noted, had repeatedly requested that the Yukon government consult with them after the office issued its recommendation. However, without ever speaking to either First Nation, the government filed the petition on May 29, 2023 — the 30th anniversary of the signing of FNNND's Final Agreement.
The government's "impoverished approach" to the Peel plan, she argued, required redress and rebuke from the court. She urged the court to send the message to the Crown that "the path to reconciliation lies in boardrooms, not courtrooms" and find the Yukon's petition an abuse of process.
Clark and FNNND's other lawyer Nuri Frame, meanwhile, defended the recommendation and said it should remain untouched, describing it as a comprehensive, "impressive" document that applied the Peel plan as intended and made sense when read as a whole.
Both lawyers took issue with several of the Yukon's and Silver47's arguments, including that it was unfair the office never told the company that the baseline data was crucial to its proposal and that the office didn't have the authority to assess conformity with the Peel plan.
Clark argued the YESAB office wasn't obligated to state a "matter that is obvious," pointing to the six information requests it issued to Silver47 during the assessment period repeatedly asking for baseline data.
A man in his 80s is dead following a fire at a North York retirement residence, according to first responders.
Every other Monday at 9 a.m., Don Hladiuk joins a Zoom call with a group of 30 to 45 students. They are eager to learn about space and astronomy, which Hladiuk is more than willing to talk about.
Freezing rain, blowing snow, ice pellets and strong winds are prompting weather alerts for much of eastern Canada.
Newfoundland and Labrador punched above its weight in sports, and 2025 gave the province the chance to shine on the national and international stages.
Visitors to Halifax would be forgiven for puzzling over the quirky routes of some of the city's main thoroughfares.
Deborah Ann Badeau listens to Country 94 radio in her small apartment. It’s been nearly a year since she moved into the transitional housing unit, after about six years living in a tent.
The walls and racks of the Accès-Loisirs Québec warehouse are overflowing with everything from hockey jerseys and skis to tennis rackets, sleeping bags, soccer cleats and even a few guitars.
Manitoba's government appears to be making progress in its commitment to expand spinal care capacity, but it's not happening fast enough for some patients, who want the province to reduce the barriers to getting out-of-province care.
Chief Cam McBride acknowledges crime has declined even as spending on police will rise to one-quarter of the city’s budget next year.
Two athletes from Prince Edward Island are one step closer to the Olympics after being selected for funding and accelerated development through the Canadian Olympic Committee’s official talent search program, RBC Training Ground.
Hamilton's new rules intended to improve apartment building conditions will roll out Jan. 1.
Environment and Climate Change Canada has issued a yellow rainfall and wind warning for Windsor-Essex.
As Jillian Popplow packed away dozens of T-shirts emblazoned with the phrase “sex, drugs & lobster rolls,” she questioned what would become of the quirky tees.