Ex-provincial prosecutor rips former colleagues’ handling of his own extortion case
CBC
Tim O’Brien pulled no punches when it came time to give his victim impact statement in front of a courtroom full of supporters on Wednesday.
The former provincial Crown prosecutor — and current federal Crown prosecutor — was the victim in an extortion case stemming from a false allegation of sexual assault in 2023.
Despite his wishes, the case was prosecuted by his former colleagues and not given to an outside agency.
“My friends and colleagues at the provincial Crown would be tasked with taking this matter to court,” he said. “They would see me speaking with police, explaining what happened and outlining my alibi, sitting on the same black couch in the same RNC interview room we routinely watched for hours when reviewing disclosure.”
In early 2023, O’Brien was the prosecutor on a case involving a man accused of sexually and physically abusing his wife — a teenager at the time — over the course of several years.
CBC News cannot name the woman due to a publication ban in the case against her husband.
According to the agreed statement of facts, the young woman came to O’Brien and told him she no longer wanted to proceed with trial, saying she lied about the allegations. They met twice, both times in the presence of a victim services worker.
After O’Brien told her he still intended to proceed with the trial against her partner, she sent him an email threatening to tell the police he sexually assaulted her during one of their meetings.
O’Brien immediately flagged the email to his boss, who notified the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary.
That sparked a pair of criminal investigations — one into O’Brien for sexual assault, and one into the woman for extortion.
“I was advised that because of the nature of your allegations, I would be investigated by the RNC as a suspect in a sexual assault,” O’Brien said in his victim impact statement.
“The embarrassment of being investigated by officers I regularly dealt with in the course of my work was unimaginable. When I provided my statement in relation to this matter, the officer read me my rights and caution and advised me that anything I said could be used as evidence in the investigation into your yet unproven report of sexual assault.”
Police also took a statement from the victim services worker who was present for both meetings, including one where O’Brien and the woman were on opposite sides of a plexiglass barrier. She told police nothing untoward happened in either meeting.
Months passed before the investigators came to a conclusion. They arrested the woman and charged her with three offences — extortion, unlawfully intimidating a justice system participant and public mischief by making false statements.
As conflict continues across the Middle East, Iranians living in Saskatchewan are worried for their families and friends back home.
For Mark Arendz, competing at the 2026 Paralympics in Milano-Cortina will mark his fifth appearance at the Games, and this one will be especially meaningful.
Scientists who study sleep are warning B.C.'s decision to adopt permanent daylight time could have a negative impact on overall health, especially for children.
Despite being raised in Canada, Negar Amedi says she has felt the impact on her family and community in Iran from the long rule of the country's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.
Truck traffic using Huron Church Road to and from the Ambassador Bridge may have to pay a new toll, if the province yields to urging from Windsor's mayor.
Several businesses operating under the Sunterra banner are seeking an appeal of a recent civil court ruling that awarded $35 million to a U.S. lender, which claimed the Alberta firm had engaged in cheque kiting.
Colin and Marty Stephenson received a call this week that left them feeling stressed and betrayed.
Thunder Bay City Council has voted down proposed, temporary changes to the city's transit service.
After years of rumours it would be forced out by a condo development, an iconic Toronto drag bar is setting the record straight.
Standing in front of a pile of bricks and rubble that had been their family business a day earlier, Lola Vidakovic, her sister Iva and their mother Vesna still can't believe the pizza shop is gone.
With 20 different sports and hundreds of youth athletes competing across multiple venues, the Arctic Winter Games needs a huge number of volunteers to be successful.
Confusing advice and on-again-off-again airport closures are complicating the evacuation of hundreds of thousands of foreigners stranded in the conflict zone around the Persian Gulf.
"Red flag" orders were billed as a faster, simpler way to keep Canadian communities safe by temporarily removing legal firearms from the hands of those who might do themselves — or others — harm. They were part of a suite of gun control measures introduced in the wake of 2020's Portapique, N.S., mass shooting, the deadliest in the country's history.