The unravelling of Danielle Smith's case for Alberta's renewables pause
CBC
If there was any doubt remaining that Alberta's nearly seven-month moratorium on renewable-energy projects was a political decision — made in the halls of power rather than in the offices of expertise — it was erased by internal documents released to the public last week.
As first reported by The Narwhal, which obtained the documents under a freedom-of-information request, the CEO of the independent Alberta Electric System Operator (AESO) was actually opposed to the moratorium. In internal communications, Mike Law said it would send a "closed-for-business message" and could drive renewable-energy investments into a "tailspin."
This, of course, flies in the face of Premier Danielle Smith's long-standing justification for the controversial policy, which has introduced all sorts of uncertainty into the province's once-bustling market for renewable-energy investment.
After announcing the moratorium last August, Smith claimed "the Alberta Electric System Operator asked for us to do a pause to make sure that we could address issues of stability of the grid."
In support of her claim, she pointed to a published letter from the AESO CEO to Utilities Minister Nathan Neudorf — even though the letter said nothing of the sort.
The internal documents now show the opposite chain of events: rather than the AESO asking the government for the pause, it was the government that asked the AESO to write a letter in support of the policy.
"As you can imagine, [CEO] Mike [Law] is not comfortable with this but he has agreed to provide the letter," AESO board chair Karl Johannson wrote in an email to fellow board members in July 2023.
"I told him to support the minister without reservation."
Seeing these contradictions spelled out in black and white may have made a splash in the news cycle, but it didn't come as much of a surprise to those in the renewable-energy industry, who have long seen Alberta's official justifications for the moratorium — which lifted in March — as divorced from reality. Besides, they say, they now have larger concerns with new restrictions on renewable projects and a looming redesign of the electricity market.
Policy experts, meanwhile, say they have serious concerns about how the provincial government misled the public as to the origin and reasons for the seven-month pause, which was accompanied by a parallel inquiry into the impacts of renewable-energy projects. They also worry about how this may affect future decisions surrounding — and investment in — Alberta's electricity market.
And there's plenty coming down the pike on both those fronts.
Vittoria Bellissimo, president and CEO of the Canadian Renewable Energy Association, says many in the industry have believed for some time that the premier's explanation for the moratorium didn't stand up to scrutiny.
"The Narwhal article was certainly very interesting but it wasn't news to industry," she said.
Smith's additional claim that the Alberta Utilities Commission (AUC) had also asked for the moratorium has been debunked, as well. And her assertion that the Rural Municipalities of Alberta (RMA) passed a motion requesting the pause has been denied by the RMA, itself.
There have been four collisions involving transport trucks in northwestern Ontario in three days, prompting renewed calls for action to address ongoing safety concerns along Highway 11-17.
Ontario’s Progressive Conservatives will huddle behind closed doors at a policy convention this weekend as some Tories question the party’s direction after nearly eight years in power.
The father of a three-year-old girl that was killed after being struck by a vehicle in Cambridge in mid-December says recent charges laid to the driver bring little comfort and relief.
The start of kindergarten can be a time of excitement or anxiety for parents, guardians and children — and also for Prince Edward Island's education officials as they try to staff schools appropriately.
Nunavut Nukkiksautiit Corporation (NNC)’s proposed hydro project is facing some backlash in Pangnirtung.
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre will take to the stage Friday for what could be one of the most important speeches of his political career as he tries to convince delegates at the party's Calgary convention to keep him in the job.
As his flight departed from Amsterdam's Schiphol airport en route to Kuwait via Istanbul, Canadian crypto fugitive Andean Medjedovic was unaware that his globe-trotting lifestyle would soon be halted.
One of the largest taxi companies in Toronto will be down to three wheelchair-accessible cabs by the end of March, as advocates and providers say the city is failing to support accessible taxi drivers.
As a deep freeze continues to envelop southwestern Ontario at the same time municipalities deal with a pressing shortage of road salt, there's a renewed focus on finding different ways to melt road ice.
Dave Lawson is a proud Canadian who has bumper stickers that say "Canada is not for sale." He's fed up with grocery products plastered with maple leaves and patriotic logos that turn out to be American imports.
The Town of Badger has issued an evacuation order for some residents as water levels on the Exploits River continue to rise.
The head of a national seniors' advocacy organization says protecting nursing home residents from sexual abuse is an important but challenging issue.
New data shows Winnipeg's fire-paramedic service fielded hundreds of reports involving the city's homeless population, but one advocate says she expects that number to go down in light of the city's limits on where encampments can be.