Supreme Court case over unilingual N.B. lieutenant-governor could have broader implications
CBC
Legal experts say a pending Supreme Court of Canada case about whether New Brunswick's lieutenant-governor must be bilingual could have much broader implications and be precedent-setting.
These could include bilingualism requirements for other high-ranking positions in the country, including elected ones, and constraints on the powers of the Governor General and others in making appointments, according to two law professors.
The country's top court announced Thursday that it will hear an appeal filed by the Acadian Society of New Brunswick over the 2019 federal appointment of former lieutenant-governor Brenda Murphy.
The Supreme Court does not give reasons when it accepts applicants who are seeking leave to appeal decisions made by lower courts.
But Michel Doucet, a professor emeritus of law at the University of Moncton and an expert in linguistic rights, notes the top court only agrees to hear issues it deems of national importance.
"So it is certainly a big step in this matter, to have the the Supreme Court of Canada finally decide the issue," he said.
The Acadian Society contends New Brunswick's lieutenant-governor is required by the Constitution to be bilingual.
Three sections of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms apply only to New Brunswick, Canada's only officially bilingual province.
Section 16(2) declares that English and French have equal status "in all institutions of the legislature and government of New Brunswick," while Section 16.1(2) requires the legislature and government to "preserve and promote" the equality of English and French.
Section 20(2) guarantees the right of any New Brunswicker to communicate with or receive services from "any office of an institution of the legislature or government of New Brunswick" in English or French.
The Acadian Society won its case in 2022 at the superior trial court for the province. Court of King's Bench Chief Justice Tracey DeWare ruled that the Charter imposes a bilingualism requirement not just on the institution but on the person holding the position of lieutenant-governor.
But the New Brunswick Court of Appeal overruled that decision last May.
It ruled that while people appointed to the position should ideally be fluent in the province's two official languages, the Charter does not impose such a requirement.
According to Doucet, the Supreme Court of Canada has historically approached language rights by saying it's not the individual who has the obligation to provide the bilingual service, it's the institution.
A Pelly Crossing, Yukon, resident said he's frustrated over the fact he's still waiting to get paid for work he did during last month's territorial election.
A few days after Michael Ma decided to cross the floor to the Liberals, Pierre Poilievre was asked whether the loss of another MP was a problem for his leadership of the Conservative Party.
Ontario released a new curriculum for kindergarten in the province on Thursday, but the shift away from “play-based” learning towards “academic rigor” is sparking concern from teachers and opposition.
Ekati Diamond Mine is getting a a $115 million loan from the Canadian government to continue operations at the mine and protect jobs, its owner announced Thursday.
Prime Minister Mark Carney reaffirmed he'll protect Canada's supply management system, as the United States signalled it's ready to fight over this country's dairy rules at the negotiating table.
It all started with a 14-year-old Indigenous boy who was sitting in jail last year, not because he couldn’t get bail, but because he had nowhere to go once released.
Several people dressed as Santa and a group of masked elves were filmed at a grocery store in Montreal on Monday night filling up carts with food.
Three of the biggest players in P.E.I.’s health-care system have reached an agreement that sets more flexible models for how many patients family doctors can and should handle.
A London man is facing charges after allegedly emailing death threats to London's city hall.
Prosecutors have withdrawn a second-degree murder charge against a man who spent 23 years in prison for the killing of a 10-year-old girl in 1989.
The Redwood Meadows fire station was badly damaged by a fire on Wednesday evening.
In a rare use of the provincial government's powers, the Department of Municipal and Community Affairs has dismissed the entire town council in Victoria, N.L., and appointed a temporary administrator to oversee the affairs of the Conception Bay North community of nearly 1,700 residents.
Police services across northern Ontario say most illicit drugs circulating in their communities are being transported from southern parts of the province, while prescription drugs diverted into the illegal market continue to pose a serious and ongoing threat.