Speaker's warrant would cause Laurentian University 'irreparable harm,' says lawyer
CBC
If Laurentian University is required to submit privileged information to Ontario's Legislative Assembly, it would cause "irreparable harm," argue legal counsel for the Sudbury university.
During court proceedings Tuesday, Laurentian's lawyers asked Chief Justice Geoffrey Morawetz of the Superior Court of Justice to stay the execution of a Speaker's warrant against the institution.
The Ontario Legislature voted unanimously on Dec. 9 to issue a Speaker's warrant that would compel Laurentian to provide the province with privileged documents related to its insolvency.
But Laurentian lawyer Fredrick Schumann said it would cause Laurentian "irreparable harm" if those documents were disclosed.
Schumann referred to the legal definition of "irreparable harm," speaking about the nature of the harm, and not necessarily its magnitude. In other words, the harm to the institution could not be repaired with financial restitution.
Schumann's colleague, Brian Gover, argued the Legislative Assembly did not have a right to privileged information because its intent would be to share that information with Ontario Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk.
Lysyk has requested privileged documents to help her conduct a value-for-money audit of Laurentian, which declared it was insolvent on Feb. 1, 2021.
In a decision last week, Morawetz determined the auditor general was not entitled to access that privileged information for her audit.
Gover called the Legislative Assembly's Speaker's warrant an "end run" to bypass the auditor general's inability to obtain the documents.
But Rick Dearden, legal counsel for the Office of the Auditor General of Ontario, used the analogy of two different train stations to counter that argument.
He said the auditor general is at one train station, and the Legislative Assembly's Speaker's warrant is at another. They are two different institutions, he said, governed by different laws.
"In my respectful submission, there is no end run," Dearden said.
Josh Hunter, counsel for the Attorney General of Ontario, also said a decision preventing the auditor general from accessing privileged information herself should not prevent the Legislative Assembly from doing so.
Hunter said that as a post-secondary institution, which has received millions of dollars from Ontario taxpayers, Laurentian falls under the jurisdiction of the Legislative Assembly.
Stampede cleaning crews may hose down the grandstand seats less often after every beer-fuelled night at the chuckwagons. And while the visiting horses might get the sort of thorough showers that Calgary humans are discouraged from enjoying, it will likely be with trucked-in water, not from the city's own depleted supplies.