South Bruce Peninsula appealing $1.67M judgement in boundary dispute with First Nation
CBC
The town of South Bruce Peninsula will appeal an Ontario Superior Court Justice's ruling last month that it pay $1.67 million in legal fees to Chippewas of Saugeen First Nation in a decades-long boundary dispute, involving Sauble Beach.
The May 21 ruling by Superior Court Justice Susan Vella also ordered the province to pay $1.28 million, and the federal government to give $322,000 to the First Nation.
The town is ordered to pay 50 per cent of the federal government's $486,784 legal costs as well.
"Canada submits that it was the successful defendant in the main issue before the court, namely the location of the reserve boundary, and that the town was the unsuccessful defendant (together with Ontario)," Vella's decision reads.
The town said it will appeal the costs award against it, adding that the cost award is suspended until the appeal is determined.
"The town firmly believes that the costs should be borne by Canada, as it alone was responsible for the identification of the reserve boundary, the survey, and the Crown patents which granted the town title to its beach," reads a statement posted on the town's website after the ruling.
"Notably, Canada admitted at trial that it breached its fiduciary duties," the statement continues.
"Justice Vella also stated that this costs order is made without prejudice to the Town's right to seek indemnification from Canada for the entire costs award in addition to its damages claim, which will be addressed in Phase 2 when compensation is determined."
A spokesperson for the town declined to comment, saying the matter is before appeal. The spokesperson directed CBC News to the town's website for more information, however no further detail about the appeal was available.
Saugeen Chief Conrad Ritchie did not return a request for comment Thursday, but said in a statement last month that he was grateful the court "recognized the significant expenses that Saugeen First Nation has incurred over the years to advance our community's rights."
"We are very pleased that the court not only recognized our rights, but has now also allowed us to recover a significant portion of our legal costs that we can direct toward supporting our community in other ways."
It follows an April 2023 ruling by Vella that a roughly two-kilometre strip of Sauble Beach, located at the northern end of Saugeen Reserve No. 29 and known as "Chi-Gmiinh" by the First Nation, has always belonged to the community, and that the federal government breached its treaty rights.
In the ruling, Vella found the Crown had failed to protect and preserve Treaty 72 from 1854, in which Saugeen First Nation and neighbouring Chippewas of Nawash surrendered Saugeen Peninsula, excluding five reserve territories, of which one would become Reserve No. 29.
When it surveyed the land in 1856 to mark out the reserve, Vella ruled the Crown did so improperly, resulting in the removal of 2.2 kilometres of land promised under the treaty – land which today spans 1st Street South to 6th Street South, west of Lakeshore Boulevard.
A Calgary dentist who defrauded five insurance companies over a decade should spend up to three years in prison, the prosecution argued Friday.
B.C. Conservation Officer Service says it has called off its search for a bear responsible for an attack on a group of school children in Bella Coola, B.C. on Nov. 20.
The union president called it a rally for solidarity as Iqaluit Housing Authority employees gathered Friday while negotiations are ongoing between the Nunavut Employees Union and the employer.
The federal government is stoking Quebec separatism by walking back its climate commitments — including in its recent deal with Alberta — Liberal MP and former cabinet minister Steven Guilbeault says.
Four more Alberta MLAs are facing recall petitions organized by their constituents, including the first NDP representative to be caught in the province's ongoing wave of recall efforts.
Frank Gehry, the Canadian-born renegade architect behind some of the world's most recognizable buildings, has died at 96.
Hundreds of P.E.I. parents can't find child-care spaces, especially for infants. The provincial government says expanding those spots remains a top priority — and it recognizes the concern.
An Alberta judge says a referendum proposal on Alberta separating from Canada goes against Charter and and Treaty rights, in a decision given less than 24 hours after the provincial government introduced legislation that would have ended the court proceeding.
The architect of Alberta's politician recall legislation says it was never meant to be used as a political weapon, but as an "ultimate tool of accountability" if a politician engages in illegal or unethical behaviour.
The Government of Saskatchewan has introduced its long-promised involuntary treatment legislation on the final day of the fall sitting.
The Law Society of Ontario has suspended the licence of Deepak Paradkar, one of seven Canadians arrested in connection with alleged drug lord Ryan Wedding’s cocaine smuggling ring.
London Health Sciences Centre (LHSC) is getting rid of unlimited mental health benefits for staff, blaming ballooning costs and former administrators for implementing it without proper due diligence or oversight.
Netflix has agreed to buy Warner Bros. Discovery's TV and film studios and streaming division for $72 billion US, a deal that would hand control of one of Hollywood's most prized and oldest assets to the streaming pioneer that has upended the media industry.