Sask. commissioner sides with Opposition MLA after conflict-of-interest complaint
CBC
Saskatchewan's conflict-of-interest commissioner found that while an Opposition member of the legislative assembly's (MLA's) social media posts about her personal company "come close to the line," they do not constitute a conflict of interest.
Jim Reiter, the current deputy premier and minister of finance among other roles, wrote to the conflict of interest commissioner in September 2024 about posts by Aleana Young, the NDP MLA for Regina South Albert.
He alleged Young used her MLA website and social media accounts to promote the brand and products of Takeaway Gourmet TGM Inc. — a gourmet cheese store in Regina that she owns and operates — in violation of The Members Conflict of Interest Act.
According to the report from conflict-of-interest commissioner Maurice Herauf, Reiter argued that, in social media posts dating back to 2021, Young had attempted to influence her social media followers, visitors to her website and the broader public to have a "positive perception" of the company's brand and products.
According to the report, the Act is breached when an MLA "uses their office to promote private interests," including attempting to influence a person's decision. Herauf said this is the first case to come to his office about social media use by members.
In his request for the commissioner's opinion, Reiter shared 42 posts he believed were in contravention of the act and also noted other times when news articles referred to her ownership of the shop and her political standing.
The posts included Young sharing an Instagram story the company made about a "savoury butter board" for $25, and a Twitter post during the pandemic that showed two photos — one of Young masked outside the Legislature and one of her handling food products at the store — captioned "get an elected official who can do both."
Young's legal counsel contested Reiter's claims on her behalf in a response in February. The report says Young argues there needs to be an actual, subjective intention to influence another person. The commissioner agreed.
"I accept her evidence that she was not intending to influence anyone in favour of the company through these posts," Herauf wrote.
"If anything, Ms. Young was trying to promote herself as a Member by projecting herself as a real, accessible and genuine MLA — not to promote the Company itself."
He compared Young's posts to members posting on social media from their family farm, which could be construed as promoting their farm business.
Herauf expressed concern that some of Young's posts about the company's products, prices, hours and seeing people at the shop "come very close to promotions," but did not find enough evidence to show Young was in violation of the act.
Herauf also said Young cannot control how the media refers to her or whether it uses her company's logo in its reporting.
In conclusion, Herauf said he is not aware of any guidance for MLAs on how to use social media when it comes to issues of conflicts of interests or expenses, and said it would be useful to establish some.
A national Jewish advocacy organization is taking legal action against Manitoba's medical regulator over a complaint it made last year alleging a prominent doctor made antisemitic comments on social media.
A cat that went missing in a remote area of northeastern B.C. is finally back home with its family in Oklahoma, five months later.
It wasn’t clear trolleys would be a hit in Medicine Hat, but the Sunshine Trolley has wound its way into Hatters’ hearts.
More than 200 volunteers and politicians gathered in Etobicoke Saturday for the Daily Bread Food Bank’s holiday sort.
The rising cost-of-living has already made supporting a family difficult this year. But, the holidays can make staying on budget that much harder.
Strong winds across the Maritimes left thousands of N.B. Power customers without electricity on Saturday afternoon — and it could be days before all customers have their power restored.
Toronto police say they located a body inside a downtown Toronto home Saturday.
Quebec Immigration Minister Jean-François Roberge is responding to public outcry against his government’s policy changes for non-permanent residents by making a plea to the federal government.
A man in Saskatoon is in hospital after being shot by police as officers executed a warrant late Friday night.
RCMP say a man who was reported missing near Key First Nation has been found deceased.
Christy Morin says life was never the same in Alberta Avenue after the fires began.
It's small things, like a cigarette or a pair of clean socks, Rachel Montour says, that can go a long way to make you feel more human when you’re out on the street.
Several dozen members of Windsor's Chaldean community and its supporters celebrated in the cold at the corner of Marentette Avenue and Wyandotte Street East Friday, as city officials gave a secondary name to the section of Marentette between Wyandotte and Tuscarora Street: Chaldean Way.