Necessity of gov't quota on caribou harvesting debated at final day of Colville Lake hearing
CBC
Lawyers representing the territorial government argued the environment minister was correct in his decision to uphold a caribou harvesting limit in Colville Lake, N.W.T.
Colville Lake is challenging a decision by the territory to set a quota on how many Bluenose West caribou can be harvested each year on its traditional territory.
The community — represented by lawyers from the Colville Lake Renewable Resources Council, Behdzi Ahda First Nation and Ayoni Keh Land Corporation — wants to see a plan that would remove the government's tag and quota system, known as total allowable harvest for the Bluenose West caribou herd.
In its place, Colville Lake would preserve the herd with a plan based on cultural and traditional values and knowledge.
Environment and Natural Resources Minister Shane Thompson rejected the idea of removing the harvest limit.
The hearing lasted three days in the Supreme Court of the Northwest Territories at the Yellowknife courthouse. It ended Thursday with submissions from Maren Zimmer and Kyle Ereaux representing the government.
The territory's lawyers pointed to provisions in the Sahtú Dene and Metis Comprehensive Land Claim that states harvesting limits would be implemented "if required for conservation."
Zimmer said that the agreement's direct reference to the limits, as well as a clause stating the government has "ultimate jurisdiction for the management of wildlife and wildlife habitat," means the minister was within his authority to uphold harvesting limits and did not breach the land claim.
Ereaux added that the minister's use of "at this time" in his decision indicates he's open to future discussions at a later time.
He told the court that the status quo will stay in place for now, but that Thompson supports the idea of conservation managed by the community and is open to collaborating on a plan moving forward.
Lawyer Senwung Luk, one of four lawyers for the applicants, emphasised the "if required" section of the agreement. In his response to the territory's lawyers, he said the plan the community is proposing would manage caribou populations without the need for total allowable harvest.
Luk said that the harvesting limits aren't working and that despite the total allowable harvest coming into effect in 2008, the Bluenose West caribou herd is still in decline. He said the community's management plan is consistent with local knowledge and Dene law. It's not "an experiment," or "a shot in the dark by any means," Luk said, arguing against language the Inuvialuit Game Council used in court Wednesday.
He said that conservation goes beyond setting a number to how many animals can be killed. It's about observing seasons and herd behaviours.
Luk said rather than upholding quantities "it's more important to teach young hunters," that, for example, harvesting an animal that's alone in cold weather, might mean that animal is the only one who knows where to get winter supplies and would impact the livelihood of the herd, despite accounting for just one tag.
Officials from the London, Ont., and several neighbouring counties will push the Ford government for improved passenger rail service in the region when they meet with the Ontario government at a conference in Toronto this month.
A provincial court judge has issued a stern warning to the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary to “rethink their approach” when it comes to dealing with complaints of threats and harassment in intimate partner relationships.
Some provincial funding targeted to struggling rural hospitals in the northeast is a boon but some CEO’s say it falls short of keeping them afloat.
A Ukrainian family in Halifax says the federal government needs to provide answers to the thousands of Ukrainians who are now learning that it could be more than 50 years before their permanent residency applications are processed.
On a cold January morning, the owners of Yassou Souvlaki & Donair in Fredericton are busy heating up the kitchen, slicing vegetables and donair meat to prepare for their lunch-hour crowd.
The Transportation Safety Board of Canada and the CN Police Service are investigating following a train collision overnight in Saint-Alexandre-de-Kamouraska, Que.
Six months after being displaced to a long-term care facility hundreds of kilometres away from his family, Jimmy Spence is holding out hope his days as an evacuee are numbered.
Saskatchewan women ages 43 and older can now sign up for mammogram screening without a doctor’s referral as part of a phased approach to get the eligibility age down to 40 by June.
Some schools, health centres and provincial civil service offices delayed opening or closed for the day on Monday due to weather conditions.
As a seasonal parking ban comes into effect on Edmonton’s residential roads this week, one councillor is concerned about how the city’s failure to fund towing teams will play out on city streets.
Students in B.C.’s biggest districts are missing significantly more school in recent years, with absences having tripled in some places, an exclusive CBC News analysis has found.
An Essex resident has been charged following a dog attack in town.
Charles Snell says he recognizes the need for more housing to be built in Thunder Bay, Ont., but that it shouldn’t come at the cost of losing green space.