N.W.T. man convicted of murder in 2018 tells court defence lawyer 'set me up'
CBC
An N.W.T. man convicted of murder and attempted murder says he was not given proper representation by his lawyer at his trial six years ago.
Kevin Mantla made the argument on Thursday before a special commissioner appointed to review the merits of Mantla's appeal.
Mantla was sentenced in 2018 to life in prison with no possibility of parole for 20 years for the second-degree murder of Elvis Lafferty and the attempted murder of Mantla's ex-girlfriend.
Mantla, 44, alleged in court on Thursday that his defence lawyers tricked him into not testifying during the trial.
"They were working behind the scenes with the Crown and victim to set me up," reads his affidavit submitted to the Court of Appeal.
Mantla also claims he "blacked out" and does not remember parts of what happened on the night that Lafferty was killed, in 2015. Mantla said in court that he has a short-term memory problem and also lost some of the notes he had earlier.
Crown prosecutor Ryan Carrier referred to the affidavits submitted by Mantla's defence counsel, which mention notes of discussions with Mantla in February 2018.
Defence lawyers, including Charles Davison, advised Mantla at that time about the severe risks of conviction due to the substantial evidence against Mantla.
There was also a written statement, signed by Mantla, confirming his decision not to testify at his trial. Mantla alleges Davison pressured him into this decision.
During cross-examination on Thursday, Carrier asked Mantla how he would have testified if he had had the chance.
"Elvis Lafferty didn't deserve to die; he was a good man," Mantla responded.
Mantla was representing himself in court on Thursday, although he received legal counsel help from John Hale, appointed by the Court of Appeal.
The Court of Appeal is scheduled to reconvene on Nov. 26 for the cross-examination of Mantla's defence counsel.
According to Carrier, the outcome of this hearing will be part of Mantla's sentencing and conviction appeal, tentatively scheduled for early 2025.
As snow squalls continue to blanket southwestern Ontario, school boards in the London region announced the closure of all schools Thursday morning, and police are reporting closures and collisions across the area roads.
A Canadian citizen has died in Iran “at the hands of the Iranian authorities,” according to Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand.
On Boxing Day, Victoria Lethbridge and her partner took their dog and baby out for a morning walk in brand new snowshoes around the corner from their home in Hickman’s Harbour.
When a U.S. company made its data centre pitch to some concerned Saint John residents late last year, he called the city an untapped “gold mine” for artificial intelligence projects.
Over the past seven years, when outgoing premier François Legault's government tabled a contentious bill, he would often justify it by saying it represented the will of the vast majority of Quebecers.
The union representing Manitoba's nurses is concerned a reduction in the number of nursing agencies the province works with could exacerbate staffing shortages during the transition period.
Developers convinced a Saskatoon city council committee Wednesday to give some more thought to proposed changes to a longstanding incentive to encourage infill.
A Regina real estate agent has been sanctioned by the Saskatchewan Real Estate Commission after he arranged to pay someone to tamper with other businesses' Google Business profiles.
Peter Bevan-Baker will not be running for re-election in the next provincial election, the Green Party of P.E.I. announced Thursday morning.
Businesses in Edmonton don’t have to recycle or compost — but that could soon change.
A day after two elderly Vancouver Island women told RCMP they had been scammed for thousands of dollars, a man walked into the detachment saying he took their money during his delivery work and was unsure if what he was doing was legal.
Schools across the Hamilton, Niagara, Burlington and Brantford areas are closed today after the area was hit with a winter storm overnight.
All school buses in Windsor and Essex County are cancelled on Thursday morning according to Windsor-Essex Student Transportation Services.