Mark Holland makes a case for a more human approach to politics
CBC
This is an excerpt from Minority Report, a weekly newsletter on federal politics. If you haven't subscribed yet, you can do that by clicking here.
"This place needs to be more human," Government House leader Mark Holland told a House of Commons committee during highly personal testimony on Tuesday.
In a narrow sense, Holland was making a case for the continued use of the "hybrid" arrangement that Parliament adopted shortly after the pandemic upended Canada and the world in 2020. At the most acute stages of the pandemic, allowing MPs to speak and vote remotely was a matter of safety. Looking forward, an openness to virtual participation could allow MPs to better balance their democratic duties with their personal lives.
In that respect, the conversation taking place in Parliament is not unlike the discussion that many workplaces have had about remote work.
But it's also possible that everything about our politics could stand to be more human — and that part of what ails modern politics is a lack of humanity.
"I think it would really miss what I'm trying to say to think it's just about hybrid," Holland said in a follow-up interview with CBC's Rosemary Barton that airs on Sunday.
"I think that there is something broken in our discourse, there's something broken in how [MPs] treat each other ... and how we talk to each other about what we do."
Although politicians are (with rare exceptions) — human beings, and although the debates they have and the policies they enact have very real implications for very real people, politicians don't always act or seem like normal people.
That's why moments of raw humanity — such as Holland's testimony on Tuesday — are often seen as revelations. It's not for nothing that commentators sometimes talk about efforts to "humanize" a politician.
Some of this might be unavoidable — the job is necessarily performative. Politicians are expected to lead and convey messages. They are a voice for others. To some extent, they have to entertain. They face constant and unforgiving media scrutiny.
As Holland noted, MPs spend their weekends racing around their ridings, going from one community event to another.
In short, there are many things about the life of a politician that would not be considered "normal" by most normal people. But politicians can also be captured by their own theatrics.
Consider, for instance, question period.
"I think we're all seized with the decline in the quality of discourse, the incredibly aggressive and partisan nature in the way we question each other and interact with one another," Holland said at another point during Tuesday's committee hearing.
When Gurdeep Khinda moved from India to Montreal 30 years ago, he thought his dream of becoming an actor on stage was over. He was too busy navigating his new life and there weren't any theatre groups in the city catering to the Indian community at the time.
More than 53,000 Manitobans have accessed birth control at no cost in the first year of the provincial government's free contraception program, the province says.
The Niagara Regional Police Pipe Band is inviting beginners and youth to try its free music program to help carry on the world-calibre musical ensemble's tradition.
Mayors of municipalities across southwestern Ontario say they’ve focused on the things they could control this year, as the U.S. trade war with Canada and the world has hammered local economies.
A house filled with snakes and spiders might be straight out of many people's nightmares, but to longtime exotic pet keeper Nolan Asplund, they’re like family.
The Ontario government is introducing new rules for publicly advertised job postings in the new year, but questions remain over whether the changes will result in tangible benefits for jobseekers.
Did you know ambulance services on Prince Edward Island were once largely provided by funeral homes?
The past 12 months brought big political headlines, new partisan players and plenty of parliamentary surprises. How much do you remember from it all?
The Ontario government has quietly given itself the power to override archaeological protections on development sites.
A freezing rain event that's left roads and trees across southwestern Ontario coated in ice has also seen emergency crews overwhelmed with calls for help from people without power and snapped trees.
Annette Dionne, the last surviving Dionne quintuplet and a champion of children's rights, has died.
The Newfoundland and Labrador government is warning of multiple scams circulating leading up to the holidays.
The painted bunting usually calls the southern U.S. home and travels south at this time of year, but one decided to spend its Christmas holidays up north in Bayfield, N.B.