Justice department backs down on request to keep evidence secret in N.B. murder trial
CBC
The federal Department of Justice has backed down from a request it made to keep the testimony of a Crown witness secret from the public in an upcoming jury trial for two people accused of murder near Fredericton three years ago.
A lawyer for Canada's attorney general had filed an application in the Court of King's Bench earlier this month seeking to have the witness testify behind closed doors during the jury trial of Joshua McIsaac and Erica Blyth, who are jointly charged with murdering Brandon Donelan in the first degree.
The application, if granted, would effectively have allowed only the jury, the judge, lawyers and their clients to hear the testimony of the Crown witness and would have kept that testimony sealed even after the trial concluded.
However, following objections from defence lawyer Nathan Gorham, as well as reporters with CBC News and the Fredericton Independent, Patricia MacPhee, a lawyer for Justice Canada, reneged on her initial request.
"There's now a tentative resolution," said MacPhee, in court, following private discussions she had with Gorham and TJ Burke, who is representing Blyth.
That resolution, as described by Gorham, would only go as far as imposing a publication ban on any information that would identify the Crown witness and their family.
Wednesday's court appearance was part of pre-trial proceedings ahead of its scheduled April 23 start date.
It comes more than three years after Donelan's body was found in a wooded area between Minto and Chipman on March 31, 2022, after being reported missing two months earlier.
Due to a publication ban on any evidence discussed prior to the trial, CBC News cannot report why the Department of Justice wanted to keep the evidence of one of the Crown witnesses secret.
In a brief filed in response to Justice Canada's original application, Gorham argued there was no factual or legal basis to have "vast portions" of the trial held in private and that it would undermine the fairness of his client's trial.
"This alone is a drastic, unprecedented request," Gorham wrote. "It is made even more outlandish by the claim that the evidence should be sealed in perpetuity."
Wednesday's proceedings were adjourned until April 9, when media outlets will be allowed to make submissions related to the proposed publication ban.
Justice Richard Petrie will have the final say on whether to grant it.
All public schools on P.E.I. are closed Friday and thousands of Maritime Electric customers are without power as strong winds create hazardous travel conditions across the province.
Prince Rupert, B.C., residents are celebrating the holidays this year with coastal flair.
In the four years Chelsey Simmonds has worked at the Eva Rothwell Centre, she has seen the need increase every year at the centre’s community food pantry.
CBC is once again looking to make the holiday season kind in Windsor-Essex.
Acute Care Alberta has extended its contract for another year with a private surgical facility at the centre of probes into health procurement and contracting.
As food bank use continues to climb across the province, front-line workers in Thunder Bay, Ont., are working to improve both food security and education.
More ads could soon be coming to Toronto’s subway system.
The driver wanted in connection with a fatal hit and run on Highway 401 earlier this week has been identified, police say.
There are mixed feelings about the proposed Grays Bay road and port project, among people who live in nearby communities.
WARNING: This story details allegations of child abuse and includes graphic content.
Provincial police in Lambton County have charged a 23-year-old man with second degree murder following a death investigation that began this past Saturday.
The Newfoundland and Labrador government is forming a working group to tackle what it calls systemic issues in the justice system, but answers or solutions could still be months away.
A woman has pleaded guilty to dangerous driving causing death in a 2024 fatal hit and run in Truro, N.S., where the victim was dragged down the street, a case that went unsolved for more than six months.