Is the promise of military icebreakers political theatre or sensible policy?
CBC
A former top naval commander and several defence experts have been left scratching their heads following the governing Liberals and Opposition Conservatives' recent embrace of the notion of giving the Royal Canadian Navy heavy, armed icebreakers to defend the Arctic.
They question the military sensibility of building — possibly at a cost of billions of dollars — one, two or even three 10,000-tonne or more polar-class icebreakers with guns and missiles, vessels with possibly limited usefulness that would be vulnerable to both air and submarine attack.
"I'm puzzled, because I don't know what it is we're trying to achieve other than the political objective of demonstrating a commitment to Arctic sovereignty. Check. I get it. However, it needs to be sensible, and more importantly, it needs to be practical," said retired vice-admiral Mark Norman in a recent interview.
Canada's defence in the Far North was a topic brought up when Prime Minister Mark Carney met with U.S. President Donald Trump in the Oval Office on Tuesday. A senior Canadian government official said the two leaders spent a lot of time talking about the Arctic.
During the recently concluded federal election campaign, the Liberals promised to "expand the capabilities of the navy with new submarines and additional heavy icebreakers," while the Conservatives were more explicit, saying they would build two additional polar icebreakers for the military.
If the promise of heavy militarized icebreakers sounds familiar, it's because it was made before. Back in 2006, the former Conservative government of prime minister Stephen Harper rode to power on a pledge to build heavy military icebreakers for the navy.
Ultimately, the high construction cost and the fact the vessels would have utility only four months of the year led to the design and creation of Arctic and offshore patrol ships (AOPS), light icebreakers which can operate and patrol off all three of Canada's coastlines. The navy plans on deploying six AOPS and the coast guard is expected to receive two.
For Norman, there is a sense of déjà vu about the renewed debate.
"We went through this very issue in 2007-08 up to the 2010-12 timeframe, where we had a government of the day that was quite explicit about what they wanted, but couldn't explain why they wanted it," said Norman.
"I get it, the government gets to decide. But at the end of the day, it doesn't make a lot of sense."
The coast guard is usually the home of Canada's unarmed icebreaking fleet. The Liberals, however, have promised to rewrite the service's mandate to conduct maritime surveillance and integrate them into Canada's NATO defence capabilities. Whether that means arming them is unclear.
Norman said there needs to be a clear division of responsibilities between the navy and the coast guard.
"We need to decide what we're trying to achieve. If it's surveillance, there's lots of other ways to achieve surveillance," said Norman. "I'm concerned because as soon as we list things that we want to buy, we lose track of what it is we're trying to achieve. And then the entire machinery [of government] becomes focused on buying something which may or may not make sense."
Canada, with 18 registered ice-capable boats, has the second-largest number of icebreakers in the world after Russia, which reportedly has 57. And only one of those Russian ships, the Ivan Papanin, is specifically built for combat and has just recently entered service. China has a handful of medium icebreakers in its navy.
There have been four collisions involving transport trucks in northwestern Ontario in three days, prompting renewed calls for action to address ongoing safety concerns along Highway 11-17.
Ontario’s Progressive Conservatives will huddle behind closed doors at a policy convention this weekend as some Tories question the party’s direction after nearly eight years in power.
The father of a three-year-old girl that was killed after being struck by a vehicle in Cambridge in mid-December says recent charges laid to the driver bring little comfort and relief.
The start of kindergarten can be a time of excitement or anxiety for parents, guardians and children — and also for Prince Edward Island's education officials as they try to staff schools appropriately.
Nunavut Nukkiksautiit Corporation (NNC)’s proposed hydro project is facing some backlash in Pangnirtung.
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre will take to the stage Friday for what could be one of the most important speeches of his political career as he tries to convince delegates at the party's Calgary convention to keep him in the job.
As his flight departed from Amsterdam's Schiphol airport en route to Kuwait via Istanbul, Canadian crypto fugitive Andean Medjedovic was unaware that his globe-trotting lifestyle would soon be halted.
One of the largest taxi companies in Toronto will be down to three wheelchair-accessible cabs by the end of March, as advocates and providers say the city is failing to support accessible taxi drivers.
As a deep freeze continues to envelop southwestern Ontario at the same time municipalities deal with a pressing shortage of road salt, there's a renewed focus on finding different ways to melt road ice.
Dave Lawson is a proud Canadian who has bumper stickers that say "Canada is not for sale." He's fed up with grocery products plastered with maple leaves and patriotic logos that turn out to be American imports.
The Town of Badger has issued an evacuation order for some residents as water levels on the Exploits River continue to rise.
The head of a national seniors' advocacy organization says protecting nursing home residents from sexual abuse is an important but challenging issue.
New data shows Winnipeg's fire-paramedic service fielded hundreds of reports involving the city's homeless population, but one advocate says she expects that number to go down in light of the city's limits on where encampments can be.