Fredericton police error collapses 3 murder cases, charges stayed against 5 people
CBC
An error by Fredericton police caused three murder cases to collapse Friday as the Crown stayed charges against five people.
Crown prosecutor Jeremy Erickson sought the stays for charges against Erica Lea Ann Blyth, Joshua John McIsaac, Devon Mark Hill Hood, Matthew David LeBlanc and Travis James Snowsell on Friday during an appearance in Burton court.
Blyth and McIsaac had been charged with first-degree murder, accused of killing Brandon Donelan, 27, of Minto. Donelan's body was found in a wooded area between Minto and Chipman on March 31, 2022, after being reported missing two months earlier.
Hood and LeBlanc were to be tried separately on first-degree murder charges alleging they killed Donelan.
Snowsell and McIsaac were charged with second-degree murder in the death of Corey Christopher Markey. Markey, 41, was shot in Fredericton's north side on Dec. 21, 2021, and died eight days later.
Staying the charges means none of the five will stand trial on the allegations.
Erickson offered no specifics when addressing Justice Richard Petrie beyond saying that the province's attorney general was exercising its authority to seek a stay.
But defence lawyer Nathan Gorham told the judge that the development was the "result of an insurmountable evidentiary issue" with a police agency involved in one of the murder investigations.
Moments after the charges were stayed, ending the cases, the Fredericton Police Force issued a statement about the development.
"The reason for the stay of proceedings is the result of an 'insurmountable evidentiary issue' linked directly to an error initiated, discovered and subsequently reported to the Crown by the Fredericton Police Force," Chief Gary Forward said in the statement.
"Our error has further detrimentally impacted on a similar major crime investigation by a partner agency."
The nature of the error was not disclosed.
Lawyers for the accused told reporters it was an unprecedented development.
Family members of the victims sobbed in court and outside it, with Donelan's sister expressing disbelief.
Provincial police in Lambton County have charged a 23-year-old man with second degree murder following a death investigation that began this past Saturday.
The Newfoundland and Labrador government is forming a working group to tackle what it calls systemic issues in the justice system, but answers or solutions could still be months away.
A woman has pleaded guilty to dangerous driving causing death in a 2024 fatal hit and run in Truro, N.S., where the victim was dragged down the street, a case that went unsolved for more than six months.
A stream of people showing up to a brightly lit front porch, each holding up a bottle of wine, spirits, or beer.
Sona Lakhoyan Olivier has been excluded from Quebec’s Liberal caucus for the duration of an investigation led by the National Assembly’s ethics commissioner, the party announced Thursday.
The head of the William Whyte Neighbourhood Association hopes a city plan to crack down on vacant properties leads to a transformation in his community.
Saskatchewan's justice minister is rejecting the latest legislative proposal from the NDP Opposition, one that the NDP says is a necessary check on government power.
The provincial government is proposing sweeping changes to citizen-led referendum questions that could put a stop to an active court case about whether it’s constitutional to ask Albertans if they agree with separating from Canada.
A proposal for a hydrogen-powered passenger rail connecting Calgary and Banff has been submitted to the federal government in the hopes of having it fast-tracked.
The P.E.I. Green Party is calling on government to release the fall fiscal update. The checkup on the province's finances is typically released sometime in October.
A main road in Inuvik, N.W.T., is closed and water is shut off for part of the town after a utilidor leak.
Immigration Minister Lena Diab sparred with her Conservative critic at a tense House of Commons committee meeting Thursday as the two disagreed on everything from immigration levels and deporting non-citizen criminals to what kind of salad they prefer.
A report by the City of Calgary presented to councillors says blanket rezoning has so far required only "minimal" upgrades to infrastructure.