5 takeaways from audit of complaints dating back to City of Charlottetown's Peter Kelly era
CBC
A redacted version has now been made public of a forensic audit looking into a whistleblower complaint over how City of Charlottetown finances were handled while Peter Kelly was chief administrative officer.
Kelly's one-time deputy CAO, Scott Messervey, outlined 18 areas of concern in a January 2019 letter to city council after Kelly fired him. At the time, councillors voted to take no further action regarding the letter,
Messervey went on to file a complaint under the city's whistleblower protection policy in December 2019. Three years later, in September 2022, councillors voted to hire outside firm BDO Canada to perform a forensic audit of matters raised in that complaint.
Kelly himself was fired without cause in May 2022, after other staff members past and present also complained about city operations and poor staff morale under his leadership.
The auditors' report was delivered to council early this month. Council voted to release a redacted version Monday evening. Here are five takeaways.
The audit generally confirms the complaints made by Messervey, finding that at least some of the transactions he outlined appear to have breached procurement and expenditure policies.
However, the auditors did not find evidence of potential fraud. They report did note that failing to pay close attention to policies and good financial practices can result in a risk of fraud.
In early February, the city said it was delaying releasing the report pending a review by lawyers to determine the potential for legal liability. On Monday night, Mayor Philip Brown said names needed to be blacked out because of requirements in the Municipal Government Act and the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act.
Names of people and companies are redacted throughout the report, as are some dates and numbers. The names of Peter Kelly and Scott Messervey — plus those of other individuals, companies and even restaurants — do not appear in the redacted version.
The audit addresses each of the 18 separate complaints made by Messervey.
Complaint #17 relates to a naming rights agreement and revenue sharing with a private group. Names from this section have been redacted.
However, CBC News has previously reported a complaint regarding naming rights and revenue sharing in relation to the Charlottetown Islanders.
Complaint #8 involved the city providing parking spaces to a private company.
CBC News has previously reported this was the Rodd Charlottetown hotel.
The Saskatchewan government has changed the provincial Correctional Services Act to reflect a ruling by the Supreme Court of Canada regarding the burden of proof for inmate disciplinary hearings.
Tyler Hellard and his debut novel, Searching for Terry Punchout, are featured on the longlist for this year's Canada Reads contest.
The NDP leadership race could be turning into a nail-biter with no clear winner in sight. But it's unclear if Canadians are tuning in.
As the prime minister gears up to visit China, his parliamentary secretary, MP Kody Blois, says Mark Carney would like to "recalibrate" Canada's once-frosty relationship with the Chinese government and look at economic opportunities for the two nations.
Ontario appears set to push ahead with a ban on declawing cats and debarking and ear cropping dogs, a move animal welfare advocates say is years overdue and doesn’t go far enough.
If you’ve ever wanted to groove to music while drinking coffee, the Kitchener Downtown BIA has you covered this winter.
Iranian Montrealers rallied in the downtown core Saturday afternoon in a show of support for the people of Iran.
A Manitoba judge says Natural Resources Minister Ian Bushie must reconsider granting permits to a company that's no longer allowed to take tourists to see polar bears in large tundra vehicles east of Churchill.
Some people from a northern Saskatchewan reserve were left without phone landline and internet services for weeks, and wonder why it took so long for SaskTel to address the issue.
Alberta’s rate cap is deepening financial losses in the province's auto insurance market, industry experts say, as a new report found auto insurers lost more than $1.2 billion in 2024.
Environment and Climate Change Canada says an atmospheric river will take aim at British Columbia's south coast this weekend as heavy rain continues to batter the north coast.
Islanders packed into the temporary location for the Charlottetown Farmers' Market Saturday, marking the first day operating on North River Road in the former Sporting Intentions space.
More than 1,000 demonstrators gathered in Richmond Hill, Ont., Saturday to show solidarity to protesters in Iran, fighting against the country’s financial collapse and the regime that led to it.