5 more First Nations join legal challenge against Bill 5 and C-5
CBC
Five more First Nations have joined a court challenge against new federal and provincial laws aimed at fast-tracking development, saying they threaten Indigenous rights.
Bill C-5, passed by Parliament last June, allows cabinet to quickly grant federal approvals for big projects deemed to be in the national interest such as mines, ports and pipelines by sidestepping existing laws, while Ontario's Bill 5 allows its cabinet to suspend provincial and municipal laws through the creation of so-called "special economic zones."
Walpole Island First Nation, along with Kashechewan First Nation, Mississaugas of the Credit First Nation, Wapekeka First Nation and Wunnumin Lake First Nation, is joining the legal challenge.
“Bill 5’s removal of the requirement for an environmental assessment of the proposed Dresden Landfill is a direct threat to my community’s wellbeing and our ability to continue to practise our way of life,” said Bkejwanong (Walpole Island First Nation) Chief Leela Thomas in a news release Jan. 27.
Laryssa Waler, spokesperson for YORK1 Environmental Waste Solutions, owners of the Dresden landfill and waste transfer facility, said it holds existing environmental compliance approvals issued by Ontario's Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks.
Lead counsel Kate Kempton of Woodward and Company Lawyers said the laws set reconciliation back 40 years. She said Indigenous nations have tried to reclaim their rights and autonomy but any law that enshrined these rights can now be ignored, “no matter what these politicians are saying publicly.”
“Both of these laws give the respective governments absolute power … to make huge decisions about massive developments on lands without applying and abiding by any other laws at that level of government," said Kempton.
Kempton said laws that threaten and provide for sweeping environmental damage including climate change are in violation of section 7 of the Canadian Charter Rights and Freedoms, the right to life, liberty and security of the person, because they cause severe mental, cultural and social distress in addition to the trauma First Nations have already endured.
She said Bill 5 and C-5 will disproportionately and unequally harm First Nations more than others and is also a violation of the right to equal effect from the law under section 15 of the Charter.
The rest of the case is about Indigenous rights under section 35 of Canada's Constitution, pinned on the 2018 decision in Mikisew Cree First Nation v. Canada, where the Supreme Court said that Crown governments have a duty to act honourably to Indigenous peoples in procedure to pass legislation, though not a duty to consult.
Kempton said their case takes precedence from the Mikisew decision to define how the government must act honourably, which has never been decided by a court before.
“Our case says it means that you can't set reconciliation back," she said.
"It means that you can't make it harder to effect reconciliation, as both of these laws do.”
Kempton said she disagrees with the Mikisew decision that Crown governments do not have a duty to consult Indigenous peoples in preparing legislation.
A First Nations family recently appeared on a popular U.S. daytime talk show to showcase their own styles of powwow dance.
People in Canada have a new, less invasive way to test for HIV at home, following Health Canada's approval of an oral self-test.
Indiana University in Bloomington, Ind., is working with Nakota communities to return valuable cultural archives of recordings of their elders.
Children face five major risk factors early in life that can set them up to develop food allergies, says a Canadian-led team of researchers who sifted through studies on 2.8 million participants in 40 countries, one of the largest reviews of its kind.
Deep within a dark growing chamber in the bowels of a research lab at Acadia University, a lumpy white substance blooms up from an industrial tray.
Most of the world doesn’t require a prescription for birth control. Why do Canadians still need one?
Leah Morris has been on birth control since she was a teenager. She remembers that first appointment being deceptively simple.
Nearly $300M in federal contracts went to companies later removed from Indigenous Business Directory
Over $285 million in federal government contracts for Indigenous businesses were awarded over a five-year period to companies that have since been removed from its Indigenous Business Directory, according to a response to a written question in the House of Commons.
The Artemis II mission, which was initially supposed to launch on Feb. 8, has now been delayed by at least a month after NASA found a hydrogen leak while fuelling the tank.
Facing the reality that a majority of Canadian students are using generative AI for schoolwork, more educators are bringing artificial intelligence into their university classrooms, setting clear rules and encouraging students to use it responsibly — and with a critical eye.
Five more First Nations have joined a court challenge against new federal and provincial laws aimed at fast-tracking development, saying they threaten Indigenous rights.
Scientists who monitor Canada’s environmental health and protect Canadians from extreme weather events and industrial disasters could soon find themselves on the federal government’s chopping block.
The federal government is reviving proposed legislation that would allow digital health information to be shared safely across electronic systems, giving both patients and providers access to more comprehensive medical records.
Some First Nations in Saskatchewan will hold information sessions about making claims under the Federal Indian Hospitals Settlement. One lawyer from Keeseekoose First Nation says having to revisit the experience can be difficult and she wants to help.