Politics and the pulpit: How white evangelicals' support of Trump is creating schisms in the Church

Goodwill Church, in New York's leafy Hudson Valley, is a special destination for The Atlantic's Tim Alberta. This was where his family's faith journey began. "There's something so deeply familiar about this place, it's hard to describe," he said. "My parents always described this church as holy ground for our family."

Tim's father, Richard Alberta, was once a pastor on this pulpit, after becoming a born-again Christian here nearly 50 years ago. "I don't know where he sat," said Alberta. "I don't know what the sermon was that day. But something happened: A guy who'd been an atheist for years, you know, decided that he was gonna give his life to Jesus."

The Alberta family later moved to Michigan, where Tim's father led Cornerstone Evangelical Presbyterian Church. "My life was completely wrapped up in the church," said Tim. "It was the sun around which we as a family revolved. It was our whole world."