Manual scavenging study reveals poverty, caste-discrimination at its roots

According to the report by Social Awareness Society for Youth, majority of the cases are not recorded properly

They know it is a inhuman and demeaning job rooted in caste-based discrimination and passed on to successive generations, but the sanitary workers continue to undertake manual scavenging as employers exploit them, and at times are cruel as well. The workers, the women especially, continue to do so to sustain the family and to educate their children so that the scourge ends with them.

These are some of the facts known from the interviews taken among the sanitary workers in the State for a study report by Social Awareness Society for Youth (SASY) on ‘The status of implementation of prohibition of employment as manual scavengers and rehabilitation (PEMSR) Act - 2013 in T.N’.

SASY, a Dalit Human Rights Organisation, studied 21 cases related to manual scavenging, sewer tank deaths, incidents of caste-based discrimination against sanitary workers and related incidents in government schools in Tamil Nadu in the year 2021-22.

According to the report, majority of the cases were not recorded properly and would not have come to light but for the social media. “When the incident happens at a private company, they immediately give some money to the victims to prevent them from filing a case against them. Most of the cases come out only when a person dies while cleaning septic tanks. Many individuals from oppressed communities are into the occupation due to poverty and are involved in handling human and animal waste especially in urban areas,”the report charged.

From the 21 fact finding cases, the report found that the victims were mostly from Scheduled Castes. Among the 21 cases, 12 were from SC Arundhathiyar, 11 from SC Adi Dravidar community, four from SC Hindu Kuravar, one from ST and one of two cases from many backward and most backward castes.

FIR was registered in 15 cases and among them, only in six cases were filed under PEMSR Act. Eight cases were filed under PoA (SC/ST) Act 2016. Of the 15 cases, only in nine cases, 15 accused were arrested. In seven cases complaints were not given reportedly owing to threats from the perpetrators. No charge-sheet was filed in any of these cases, and so no case came to court trial, the report said.

According to data from the National Commission for Safai Karamcharis, in the past 29 years (1993-2022), a total of 989 members died in various parts of the country while cleaning underground sewage tanks. Tamil Nadu reported the highest number of deaths of manual scavengers. During the period from 2016 to 2020, in Tamil Nadu 55 persons died while cleaning septic tanks. Chennai holds the highest with 12 deaths. In 2022, from January to July, 12 members died.