First Nations not in contempt of court in ongoing elver lawsuit, judge rules
CBC
A judge has thrown out a contempt-of-court accusation against several New Brunswick First Nations and their chiefs in an ongoing elver fishery dispute.
The decision, read by Justice Arthur Doyle in Saint John Court of Kings Bench on Monday, is related to a larger lawsuit filed by Mary Ann Holland of Brunswick Aquaculture and Alder Seafood, where she alleges Indigenous fishers were "poaching" young American eels in her licensed waterways and harassing her employees.
In 2022, a judge ordered First Nations members to stop fishing in the the waterways designated to Holland by the Department of Fisheries and Oceans until the case is resolved.
This spring, Holland said the First Nations are defying that order. She said they continued to fish there, specifically in the Chamcook Stream near Saint. Andrews and disrupt her employees' equipment.
After hearing testimony from Holland and two chiefs, Doyle said he does not think there's enough evidence to support that accusation.
Holland's evidence included a conversation with two unidentified people who claimed the chief of one of the First Nations said they're allowed to fish there.
In their testimony, Chief Alan Polchies of Sitansisk and Chief Ross Perley of Neqotkuk denied encouraging or telling people to break the judge's order. They testified that they've had meetings, posted notices and communicated door-to-door with people, urging them to fish in designated areas and informing them of the legal consequences of going against the judge's ruling.
"I accept the evidence that Chief Alan Polchies and Chief Ross Perley as credible and reliable," Doyle said. "In my view, there is no credible and reliable evidence ... indicating that the unauthorized fishers in this case are members of the defendant First Nation communities."
The decision comes two days after the Department of Fisheries and Oceans halted the elver fishery in Nova Scotia and New Brunswick for 45 days over "conservation and safety concerns." No one is allowed to fish elvers now, including Wolastoqey who have received a commercial-communal elver licence this year.
In 2022, elvers sold for $5,000 per kilogram. The Maritime fishery is worth about $40 million a year. The live eels are exported to Asia, where they're grown to market size.
Holland's lawsuit is against four First Nations: Neqotkuk (formerly Tobique), Sitansisk (formerly St. Mary's), Welamukotok (formerly Oromocto), and Woodstock First Nation, along with their chiefs and some unnamed individuals.
Holland said she has been fishing elvers since the 1980s, and has "exclusive rights" to fish elvers in a number of waterways in southwest New Brunswick, including the Magaguadavic River near Saint George and in the St. Croix area.
In 2022, she applied for an injunction to stop the people she's suing from allegedly fishing her waterways, and threatening and intimidating her employees, until the case is resolved. Justice Danys Delaquis granted the injunction.
The elver season began in late March. On April 3, Holland filed an affidavit saying approximately 40 people, whom she identified as Indigenous and not her employees, were fishing for elvers on the river.
Lawyers for a man acquitted in a high-profile Toronto murder trial where a police officer was killed are holding a news conference Thursday to address a recent Ontario Provincial Police report that re-examines evidence from the trial.
Quebec provincial police arrested two men after a suspicious package grounded flights headed to Montreal's Pierre Elliott Trudeau International Airport on Wednesday.
A nurse in Winnipeg says Canada's immigration system is undercutting efforts to address a shortage of health-care workers, after his application for permanent residency was rejected based on a technicality.
This year's provincial budget is "essentially" the status quo for wildfire preparation and response, the finance minister says.
Parts of B.C.'s coast continues to see heavy rain as Environment and Climate Change Canada warns of a prolonged atmospheric river this week.
Alberta teachers say they face increasingly dangerous conditions at school, with the most common threat coming from their own students.
Cataract surgeries at Charlottetown’s outpatient clinic are expected to resume in April, after procedures scheduled for March were cancelled due to the clinic reaching its annual funding target earlier than expected.
Shannon Elgazzar can see planes taking off from Cairo International Airport from her balcony.
Yellowknife city council has voted in favour of signing an agreement with the federal government that's aimed at bringing piped water and sewer service to the city's airport.
While Canada's economy is far more reliant on exports to the U.S. than vice versa, Canadian negotiators have crucial ammunition in their efforts to land a trade deal that reduces or eliminates tariffs imposed by U.S. President Donald Trump.
Nova Scotia PC MLA Rick Burns says he and his wife are victims of blackmail after hackers accessed and shared videos and intimate images on his personal devices this week.
The Saint John Board of Police Commissioners and Chief Robert Bruce have lost a bid to permanently deny public access to all court documents related to conduct complaints nine officers filed against the chief.
With the looming October election, Quebec Finance Minister Eric Girard has delivered a modest budget as the province aims to withstand ongoing trade disruptions and mounting geopolitical pressure.