'Bad for parents': School choice supporters protest exclusion of religious charter in Supreme Court case

As the Supreme Court hears St. Isidore v. Drummond, school choice advocates rally for religious charter schools, arguing for equal access to public funds — while critics warn of blurred lines between church and state.

The case, St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School v. Drummond, challenges a ruling by the Oklahoma Supreme Court that struck down a contract establishing St. Isidore – a publicly funded, Catholic online school – as a violation of state and federal law. Now before the U.S. Supreme Court, advocates argue that excluding religious schools from state-run charter programs amounts to unconstitutional discrimination.

"The court has time and time again said that the Free Exercise Clause demands that the government treat religious and secular organizations the same, and that’s not what happened here. The state excluded St. Isidore simply because of its religious character, that’s wrong and bad for parents," said Kate Anderson, an attorney at ADF working on the case.