A settlement in a U.S. lawsuit could upend the cornerstone of real estate industry: commissions

The cost of selling a home in the United States may be about to change dramatically.

A real estate trade group has agreed to a landmark deal to drop what was once a cornerstone of the industry: the six per cent sales commission paid to agents.

In Canada, two lawsuits filed against various real estate bodies want the courts to come to the same conclusion and force wholesale change in the way Realtors charge their fees when a home is sold.

"We got here by a cartel of brokerages and real estate associations that control the rules, and they've done it for a very long time," said Garth Myers, a litigator with Toronto law firm Kalloghlian Myers.

He filed the proposed class-action lawsuits in Federal Court on behalf of plaintiffs who allege that the Canadian Real Estate Association, the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board and several local brokerages and franchisors conspired to set fees and illegally drive up the price of real estate commissions.

At the heart of both the U.S. and Canadian cases is the opaque way in which real estate agents charge their fees.

In Canada, there are different fee structures in different jurisdictions. In Ontario, for example, a commission of five per cent of a home's sale price is split between the buyer's and seller's agents.

With the average price of a Toronto home at $1,225,000 last month, Realtor fees would amount to $61,250.

In Vancouver, Realtors charge seven per cent on the first $100,000 of the sale price, and between 2.5 and three per cent on the balance. So agents would split between $29,500 and $34,000 in fees on a $1-million home.

In the U.S., agents generally charge a commission of five or six per cent.

But what is common among those different jurisdictions is that the fee paid to the buyer's agent is baked into the price of the home, while a seller can negotiate with their agent and get a better fee.

A potential buyer can look up the details of a home on something called the Multiple Listing Service (MLS). The listing includes everything they would want to know about a property — from size and taxes to upgrades and amenities — but it doesn't disclose the amount a buyer will pay in Realtor fees.

Myers said the existing system enables agents to steer clients away from homes that aren't paying the full commission.

"It's clear to us that consumers are being ripped off, it's clear to us that the rules elevate the cost of buyer brokerage commissions," he said. "Now the open question that the court is going to have to resolve is whether this is criminal conduct under the Competition Act. And that's what we're fighting about in court."